Feature | August 30, 2011

Low-Risk Patients Fare the Same With Transcatheter Aortic Valve vs. Surgery

August 30, 2011 – Results from a study presented at the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Congress 2011 show that transcatheter aortic-valve implantation (TAVI) in low-risk patients met with 100 percent procedural success (versus 95.3 percent in the high Euroscore group (p=0.1). While researchers expected a lower mortality among patients with low Euroscore, the observed difference was much greater than anticipated.  In fact, the mortality rates with the Edwards Sapien valve have approached the results with conventional surgery.

The results represent a first step towards a broader assessment of percutaneous techniques in populations at lower surgical risk but without forgetting that surgery is currently the gold standard, said Matthieu Godin, M.D., from the University Hospital of Rouen, France.

“The most interesting point to observe is the absence of death at one month in the low Euroscore group, versus a mortality rate of 11.1 percent in the high Euroscore group (>20 percent), (p < 0.04) and this result is confirmed at one-year with 5 versus 24.8 percent, (p<0.01). While we were expecting a lower mortality among patients with low Euroscore, the observed difference was much greater than anticipated. In fact, the mortality rates have approached the results with conventional surgery,” Godin said.

Aortic stenosis is the most frequently acquired valve disease in adults. Two percent are symptomatic and thus should require aortic valve replacement because, in this disease, a long latency is followed by rapid progression after the appearance of symptoms, with more than half of patients dying within two years. It can be estimated that with the aging population, within 15 years, the number of aortic stenosis patients will double.

After more than 15 years of research, the first-in-man percutaneous valve implantation was performed in the center at the University Hospital of Rouen by Alain Cribier in April 2002. Since then, about 40,000 patients have been implanted worldwide with the use of two different models of valve: the balloon expandable valve and the self-expanding device. The CE mark was obtained for both in 2007. TAVI can today be proposed as an alternative treatment and has recently demonstrated its great efficiency with the results of the pivotal PARTNER-US trial. 
Based on the recommendations of both the ESC and the European Society of Cardiac Surgery, most of the registries have so far only included patients with high logistic Euroscore > 20 percent (a system developed to predict the operative mortality of coronary surgery).

In view of the overall good results in this high-risk population, a significant trend to include lower risk patients in Europe has been observed. The last registries have seen their Euroscore decreasing to 15 percent and some prospective trials are planned to include patients whatever their score.

“We sought to evaluate the results obtained in our subgroup of patients with a low Euroscore. It does not mean that the patients were at very low risk for TAVI, since they had been considered as having surgical contraindication, which did not affect the Euroscore (radiotherapy, corticosteroids, thoracic deformation or porcelain aorta). However, the patients were often less sick and younger and it seemed interesting to assess the results in this population,” said Godin.

This study is a retrospective study from all 177 patients implanted with the Edwards prosthesis at the Rouen center between May 2006 and January 2011. Patients were divided into two groups according to their predictive Logistic Euroscore: High Euroscore (>20 percent) vs Low Euroscore (<20 percent).

For more information: www.escardio.org

Related Content

St. Jude Medical, Portico, TAVR, larger valves, 27 mm, 29 mm, aortic stenosis, CE Mark

Portico TAVR System image courtesy of St. Jude Medical

News | Heart Valve Repair| September 18, 2015
St. Jude Medical Inc. announced European CE Mark approval for the 27mm and 29mm Portico transcatheter aortic valve...
News | Heart Valve Repair| September 15, 2015
coramaze technologies GmbH, a German medical device company, announced the closing of a EUR 4.5 million (US$ 5.15...
Valtech Cardio, Cardioband, CE Mark approval, mitral valve repair

Cardioband image courtesy of Valtech Cardio Ltd.

News | Heart Valve Repair| September 14, 2015
Startup cardiovascular device manufacturer Valtech Cardio Ltd. announced it has received CE Marking for its Cardioband...
Carillon mitral contour system, cost-effective, optimal medical treatment, OMT, TITAN, functional mitral regurgitation, FMR

Carillon mitral contour system image courtesy of Cardiac Dimensions Inc.

News | Annuloplasty Rings| September 10, 2015
The Carillon mitral contour system is projected to be a cost-effective treatment option when compared to a typical...
Maquet, extracorporeal life support, ECLS, cardiogenic shock, bridge-to-life, PLS system

PLS system image courtesy of Maquet

News | ECMO Systems| September 08, 2015
In a new study reported in The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, researchers found a dramatic difference...
Valtech, cardioband, transcatheter mitral annuloplasty

Valtech's Cardioband transcatheter mitral annuloplasty system in development. It is uses a series of corkscrew anchors, similar to those used on EP implantable device leads, to install the annuloplasty ring to reshape the valve for improved leaflet coaptation.

Feature | Structural Heart| September 02, 2015
September 2, 2015 — HeartWare International Inc.
Mitralign, Percutaneous Tricuspid Valve Annuloplasty System

Mitralign's Percutaneous Tricuspid Valve Annuloplasty System uses catheter delivered pledgeted sutures that can be cinched together to change the valve annulus geometry to help eliminate valvular regurgitation. 

News | Heart Valve Repair| August 31, 2015
August 31, 2015 — Mitralign Inc. said the U.S.
melody valve

Max Page and his father Buck share a pre-operation moment on morning of July 30 Melody transcatheter valve procedure at Children's Hospital Los Angeles.

News | Structural Heart| August 28, 2015
August 28, 2015 — Cardiologists from Children’s Hospital Los Angeles successfully implanted a...
News | Cath Lab| August 26, 2015
August 26, 2014 — The Cardiovascular Research Foundation (CRF) announced the late-breaking trials and first report in

Mitral regurgitation viewed under color Doppler. Image courtesy of Toshiba.

Feature | Heart Valve Repair| August 26, 2015
August 25, 2015 — Medtronic announced it entered a definitive agreement to acquire Twelve Inc., a start–up medical de
Overlay Init