Feature | April 08, 2011

Mitral Valve Repair by Catheter Compares Favorably With Open-Heart Surgery

The transcatheter MitraClip mitral valve repair system continues to compare favorably with conventional open-heart surgery for treatment of select patients with mitral regurgitation. The findings come from updated research from the EVEREST II study presented at the American College of Cardiology’s 60th Annual Scientific Session.

Mitral regurgitation (MR) is common in aging hearts, appearing in 20 percent of echocardiograms for people older than 55. A loosely closing mitral valve leaks blood back into the heart, which responds by trying to pump harder. MR is progressive, and over time the overworked heart enlarges and weakens. Each year 250,000 people in the United States learn they have MR, but only 20 percent eventually undergo standard treatment to repair or replace the valve, which is open-heart surgery that puts patients on a heart-lung bypass machine. For many, that procedure poses too great a risk. Instead they rely on medications to reduce MR symptoms, and limit their activities as physical function declines. Symptoms of MR can include palpitations, shortness of breath, fatigue, lightheadedness, cough and swelling in the legs and feet from fluid buildup.

The percutaneous MitraClip involves a minimally invasive procedure that may make valve repair feasible for more people with MR. Cardiologists trained to use this system guide a catheter-mounted device through an incision in the groin, into the femoral artery and on to the heart. When the device is properly placed, it clamps the edges of the faulty valve together like a clothespin. Sometimes a second clip is inserted for better control of MR. Standard MR surgery and device insertion both take about two hours, but their hospitalization and recovery times differ greatly.

“After getting a MitraClip, patients spend one or two nights in the hospital versus five to seven days after open-heart surgery, and they’re back to full activity immediately,” said Ted Feldman, M.D., director of the cardiac catheterization laboratory at NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, Ill., and the study’s co-principal investigator. “Traditional open-heart surgery has a recovery time of one to three months. The contrast is pretty striking.”

This phase II study enrolled 279 patients in 37 North American centers who met criteria for mitral valve surgery: grade 3+ (moderate to severe) or 4+ (severe) MR. All patients had valve anatomy suitable for the procedure and were randomly assigned in a 2-to-1 ratio to the MitraClip or to standard surgery. Both groups were well matched for baseline patient characteristics. Year one data have been published. This presentation reports year two data and patients will be followed for five years.

The effectiveness of the two treatments was measured by a composite of freedom from death, no new mitral valve surgery and MR lower than pretreatment minimum of 3+. In the treatment comparison, 101 patients (62.7 percent) in the percutaneous group met the composite endpoint vs. 66 (66.3 percent) in the surgery group. At two years, 78 percent of patients with the device did not need surgery.

Major adverse events at 30 days were significantly lower in the percutaneous group (15 percent vs. 47.9 percent). Blood transfusions of two units or more account for most of this difference: 13.3 percent in the percutaneous group vs. 44.7 percent for surgery patients.

Durability and anti-clotting drugs are other issues considered in this research. A mechanical heart valve lasts 35 years and requires the patient to take warfarin for life. Valve repair with a MitraClip should last approximately 15 years, and after implant, patients take clopidogrel for just one month and aspirin for six months. Although the procedure’s surgical version has demonstrated durability for more than 12 years, long-term outcomes from MitraClip can be defined only after further study.

“Both procedures reduced mitral regurgitation and produced meaningful clinical benefits, with the MitraClip valve repair increasing safety and surgery decreasing mitral regurgitation more completely,” Feldman said. “Our two-year data indicate that the percutaneous procedure is a therapeutic option for certain patients with significant mitral regurgitation.”

The EVEREST II study (Endovascular Valve Edge-to-Edge REpair STudy) is funded by Evalve, which also provides research funding to NorthShore University HealthSystem. Feldman is a consultant to Abbott, which acquired Evalve in 2009.

These findings will concurrently be published in the New England Journal of Medicine.

For more information: www.cardiosource.org

Related Content

News | Cardiac Diagnostics| June 24, 2016
Measuring antibody levels in the blood could be used to detect a person’s heart attack risk after researchers, part-...
Zoll LifeVest wearable defibrillator, WEARIT-II Registry results, CardioStim EuroPace 2016
News | Defibrillator Monitors| June 21, 2016
Zoll Medical Corp. announced that patients experience a high one-year survival rate following use of the LifeVest...
News | Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICD)| June 14, 2016
Medtronic plc announced results from several feasibility studies evaluating a new approach to implantable cardioverter...
hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, HCM, strain echocardiography, risk assessment, ASE 2016
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound| June 13, 2016
After following a large sub-set of patients, researchers found that by using strain echocardiography they could...
ASE 2016, Mayo Clinic study, echocardiography, aortic flow rate, patient risk stratification
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound| June 13, 2016
Researchers from Mayo Clinic believe they have found a better way to risk stratify some of their most fragile patients.
hemmorhagic stroke, blood pressure management, ATACH II trial, NINDS

Brain scan showing damage caused by bleeding during a hemorrhagic stroke. Image courtesy of Adnan I Qureshi, M.D., University of Minnesota.

News | Stroke| June 09, 2016
June 9, 2016 — An international stroke study
Medtronic, Micra TPS pacemaker, Global Clinical Trial, Cardiostim 2016
News | Pacemakers| June 09, 2016
Medtronic plc announced new results from the Medtronic Micra Transcatheter Pacing System (TPS) Global Clinical Trial in...
TeleHealthRobotics, Tele-Robotic Ultrasound, TRUDI, robotic ultrasound

The Tele-Robotic Ultrasound for Distance Imaging (TRUDI) system uses a robotic arm so a remote sonographer can control the echo probe without the need for them to be in the same room or even be in the hospital during an exam or procedure. 

News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound| June 09, 2016
June 9, 2016 — The American Society of Echocardiography (ASE) will host Echovation Challenge 2016, a competition for
heart failure, muscle bleeding, British Cardiovascular Conference, MRI
News | Heart Failure| June 08, 2016
The amount a heart ‘bleeds’ following a heart attack can predict the severity of future heart failure, according to...
Overlay Init