Feature | Business | December 18, 2007| Dave Fornell

Don’t Overlook the Simple Questions When Purchasing New Technology

Common sense is probably the biggest factor to use as a guide when looking to buy new medical technology and equipment. However, sometimes emotions, territorial department heads, old-school resistance to change and personal preferences influence or override the decision-making process in any profession. To overcome these issues, the basis for any medical evaluation committee should make it a priority to answer one central question: What is best for the patient?

When I attended the 2007 American Society of Anesthesiologists annual meeting in San Francisco in October, I listened in on a refresher course for evaluating new technology, presented by John Abenstein, M.D., Department of Anesthesiology at the Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minn.

He said committees need to establish criteria for evaluating new technology. The key questions include: Does the technology work, what studies confirm its effectiveness, can the technology work in a real-life situation as opposed to a clinical research facility and will it make clinically relevant differences in outcomes?

A committee should consider if the old equipment still has technical support and if spare parts are available. Will the new equipment do more and will it save time and money? What problem is the new technology going to solve? Dr. Abenstein suggests visiting the factory to see how the devices are made. Is the factory clean and organized? If not, he questions the quality of the machines.

He says to figure in the stability of a company. If a company is not in business three years after you purchase equipment, it will not help your long-term use of the equipment.

All sorts of justifications will be used to sway people to believe new technology is needed. Dr.Abenstein said people should not buy into emotional appeals that the technology is needed for children's or women’s health or else the hospital will not be supporting those causes. He says the bottom line is to ask if the new technology works and if it will significantly improve outcomes and be cost effective.

Some will argue equipment is needed to meet a regulatory mandate. If that argument is used, committees should ask to see the mandate in writing. Dr. Abenstein said many times it is not a mandate, but rather a suggested guideline.

Committees should also look at patient safety issues and consider standardization as a goal. If a hospital uses numerous types of machines for the same function it can lead to errors due to confusion between the different operabilities, or people not knowing how to use a machine they are not used to.
 

Related Content on the Basics of Evaluating New Technology

The Basics for Evaluating New Technology

Four Key Themes Emerging in the Medical Technology Market

Drawing the Line When Evaluating Cost vs. Benefit

Related Content

News | Business| January 16, 2018
American College of Cardiology (ACC) Chief Executive Officer Shalom “Shal” Jacobovitz will be leaving the College...
CMS Launches New Voluntary Bundled Payments Model
News | Business| January 10, 2018
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (Innovation Center)...
Toshiba Medical Systems Changes Name to Canon Medical Systems Corp.
News | Business| January 08, 2018
January 8, 2018 — Canon Inc. and Canon Medical Systems Corp.
CMS Announces Final Changes, Cancellations of Mandatory Bundled Payment Models
News | Business| December 21, 2017
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) last week finalized the cancellation of the mandatory hip...
Catheter reprocessing can reduce costs in the cath and EP lab.
Feature | Business| December 19, 2017 | Lars Thording
As payers and other healthcare entities look to better manage costs, especially in the acute care setting, it is impo
FDA Issues Final Guidance on Investigational Device Exemption Categorization
News | Business| December 19, 2017
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recently issued a final guidance, “FDA Categorization of Investigational...
Congressional Budget Office Finds cutting ACA insurance mandate will cause 13 million people to become uninsured, higher insurance premiums. American Heart Association (AHA), #AHA2017
News | Business| December 06, 2017
December 6, 2017 — At the American Heart Association (AHA) annual meeting in November, a group of 16 non-partisan pat
5 Tips for Medical Device Engineers on FDA Design Controls
Feature | Business| November 24, 2017 | Jon Speer
If you are an engineer in the medical device industry, you probably have a love/hate relationship with the FDA-mandat
Videos | Business| November 09, 2017
A discussion with Peter L.
SCAI Successful in Securing Inpatient Status for AMI-PCI Patients
News | Business| November 09, 2017
In the Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions’ (SCAI) comment letter to the Centers for Medicare...
Overlay Init