News | October 16, 2007

Jury Renders Alleged Patent Infringement “Willful”

October 17, 2007 - After a three-week trial, a jury rendered a verdict of "willful" patent infringement in a dispute filed against CHF Technologies, Inc., d/b/a BioVentrix, after Chase Medical sued BioVentrix alleging its Blue Egg Sizer, a hollow, blue silicone device used to guide surgeons in surgically resizing the heart, infringed patents held by Chase.

Chase claimed the Blue Egg Sizer was similar to its balloon-like apparatus used in similar procedures.

Chase's case focused primarily on obsolete marketing material, website content that was retracted in early 2005 by BioVentrix, and an abandoned patent application.

Arthur Bertolero, Co-Founder of BioVentrix, said, “We were very careful of the plaintiff's intellectual property when we designed the Blue Egg. We looked at the limitations imposed by their device and produced something very different, a substantial improvement over the Chase device. We never intended to infringe and are concerned that the jury found an intentional breach. We are respectful of the importance and sovereignty of the patent process, and are disappointed with the verdict."

As for what BioVentrix will do in case of an unfavorable ruling, Kenneth Miller, President and CEO of BioVentrix, stated, "We recognize the authority of the Federal Court and the jury system, and will abide by the Judge’s final ruling, but remain confident that we will ultimately prevail.”

For more information:

Related Content

CMS considers eliminating cardiac bundled payments.
Feature | Business| August 16, 2017 | Dave Fornell
August 16, 2017 — The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) announced a proposed rule to reduce the number
Sponsored Content | Videos | Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD)| July 25, 2017
This video case study, provided by Gore Medical, is titled "Tackling Complex Cases in Dialysis Access," by John Ross,
Sponsored Content | Videos | Cardiovascular Surgery| July 19, 2017
This video educational session, provided in partnership with the American Society of Echocardiography (ASE), is title
tandemLife Tandemheart priming tray cleared by FDA
Technology | Hemodynamic Support Devices| June 12, 2017
June 12, 2017 — TandemLife began its commercial launch of the TandemLife Priming Tray, a new product designed to simp
Sponsored Content | Videos | EP Lab| May 26, 2017
DAIC Editor Dave Fornell takes a tour of some of the most innovative new electrophysiology (EP) technology at the 201
Intensive Glycemic Control Program Produces Significant Per-Patient Cost Savings for CABG Surgery
News | Cardiovascular Surgery| May 25, 2017
A new study from Emory University observed a near-20 percent reduction in perioperative complications, a 1.2-day...
Risk of Heart Transplant Rejection Reduced by Desensitizing Patient Antibodies
News | Cardiovascular Surgery| May 23, 2017
The risk of heart transplant rejection can be reduced by desensitizing patient antibodies, according to research...
Heartware HVAD recall for its ventricular assist device from Medtronic
Feature | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| May 05, 2017
May 5, 2017 — Medtronic Mechanical Circulatory Support is expanding its recall of its HeartWare Ventricular Assist De
Scientists Show How Cells React to Injury From Open-Heart Surgery
News | Cardiovascular Surgery| May 04, 2017
Cedars-Sinai Heart Institute investigators have learned how cardiac muscle cells react to a certain type of injury that...
Overlay Init