Dave Fornell, DAIC Editor

Dave Fornell, Editor DAIC

Blog | Dave Fornell, DAIC Editor | December 07, 2012

Impella May Create a New Gold Standard for Hemodynamic Support

Two key news items in September made me think about the future direction of hemodynamic support, and that intra-aortic balloon pumps (IABP) will increasingly face a more serious challenge from small percutaneous left ventricular assist devices (pLVAD).  This was reinforced when I received a cardiology market analysis from GlobalData agreeing with this assessment.

Since the 1970s, IABPs have been the gold standard for hemodynamic support in low ejection fraction patients, especially those with myocardial infarction complicated by cardiogenic shock. However, when IABPs were first introduced, there was no U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) clinical trial requirement to prove efficacy.  So, until now, only a few registry studies and clinical trials have shown IABPs can improve blood pressure and coronary perfusion. Based on this limited data, international guidelines recommend the use of IABPs for cardiogenic shock. 

Use of IABPs for cardiogenic shock is estimated at 25-40 percent of cases.  This low rate may be due to cardiologists who are still not entirely convinced of IABP efficacy. The IABP-SHOCK II trial aimed to provide evidence IABPs can reduce the 30-day mortality rate compared to standard medical therapy.  But, instead of showing the superiority of IABP therapy, 30-day results from the large, randomized, multicenter trial did not meet the pre-specified 12 percent improvement in survival endpoint. Although IABPs proved to be safe, the study provided little evidence that they are associated with hemodynamic improvement, failing to reduce rates of mortality, and showing no improvement in blood pressure, no reduction in time in the intensive care unit and no improvement in organ perfusion.

This data came out at the same time Abiomed announced FDA clearance for its improved Impella CP (Cardiac Power) pLVAD. It is the same size as the Impella 2.5 liter-per-minute device, but delivers up to 4 liters per minute, representing about 80 percent of the blood flow in a normal heart.  The lower-output 2.5 device showed it provided more hemodynamic support than IABPs in previous Abiomed-sponsored studies (Maquet and Teleflex say their balloons provide between 0.5 and 1 liter of augmentation support).  The higher-output Impella CP will place the device head and shoulders above the support IABPs can provide. 

Despite the apparent advantages of pLVAD therapy (CardiacAssist’s TandemHeart and the Abiomed Impella), GlobalData said several randomized, controlled trials demonstrated a better hemodynamic profile compared to IABP, but pLVAD use did not translate into improved 30-day survival.  The Impella CP may change this. But even if it does not, supporters of IABPs say their use increases perfusion, and in that regard the Impella CP has a verifiably higher ability to do so. Impella’s higher cost compared to IABPs will likely be the biggest barrier to wider adoption.

Related Content

Heartmate PHP
News | Hemodynamic Support Devices| October 30, 2015
October 30, 2015 — Results from the SHIELD I (Coronary InterventionS in HIgh-Risk PatiEnts Using a Novel Percutaneous
Sponsored Content | Videos | Heart Failure| October 30, 2015
Manesh Patel, M.D., associate professor of medicine, and director of interventional cardiology and the cath labs at D
St. Jude Medical, HeartMate 3 LVAD System, CE Mark approval, left ventricular assist device

Image courtesy of St. Jude Medical

News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| October 28, 2015
St. Jude Medical Inc. announced the company has received CE Mark approval for the HeartMate 3 Left Ventricular Assist...
Aortix device, TCT, Interventional Innovation Shark Tank Competition, catheter-based circulatory heart pump

Image courtesy of Procyrion

News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| October 06, 2015
The novel Aortix device has earned a spot among the diagnostic and therapeutic modalities accepted for presentation in...
Procyrion, Aortix device, grand prize, Create the Future Design Contest

Aortix device image courtesy of Procyrion Inc.

News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| October 05, 2015
Procyrion Inc. of Houston has been awarded the grand prize of $20,000 in the 2015 "Create the Future" Design Contest...
Freedom Driver, SynCardia, recall, Total Artificial Heart, TAH-t, part failure

Freedom Driver attached to Total Artificial Heart. Image courtesy of SynCardia.

News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| September 18, 2015
SynCardia Systems initiated a Class I recall of the Freedom Driver Systems used with the company’s temporary Total...
Thoratec, HeartMate II LVAS, Urgent Device Correction Letter, Pocket System Controller, backup battery
News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| September 16, 2015
Thoratec Corp. issued a voluntary Urgent Medical Device Correction Letter to all hospitals who have patients supported...
HeartWare, ENDURANCE2 trial, destination therapy, HVAS, HeartWare Ventricular Assist System
News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| August 11, 2015
HeartWare International Inc. announced that enrollment in the ENDURANCE2 destination therapy clinical trial has been...
Mayo Clinic, LVAD, study, heart failure, restrictive cardiomyopathy, RCM

Thoratec HeartMate II image courtesy of Thoratec

News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| August 07, 2015
Mayo Clinic is announcing results of a study on the effectiveness of left-ventricular assist devices (LVAD) in treating...
FDA, warning, LVADs, left ventricular assist devices, Thoratec, HeartMate II, HeartWare, HVAD
News | Ventricular Assist Devices (VAD)| August 06, 2015
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is alerting healthcare providers, patients and caregivers about serious...
Overlay Init