Feature | March 27, 2012

New Medicare Rule for ICDs Adds Cost Without Improving Outcomes

March 27, 2012 — The cost to place an implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) increased by $844 per case after a new requirement from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) went into effect in February 2010, which has added little additional benefit for patients. This was according to research presented during the American College of Cardiology's (ACC) 61st Annual Scientific Session this week in Chicago.

That cost, if applied to the approximately 150,000 ICDs implanted in the United States each year, translates to $126 million in additional medical costs. The cost increase results from a new CMS requirement mandating that practitioners providing deep sedation be independent from the practitioner performing an invasive procedure. Previously, nurses administered limited deep sedation under the careful scrutiny of the implanting physician during ICD procedures; now, the implants require an additional physician such as an anesthesiologist.

“There was little evidence to support the policy change with regard to patient safety or outcomes,” said Osama Abdel-Hafez, M.D., an internal medicine resident at the Indiana University School of Medicine and the study’s lead author. “A policy that increases costs significantly without improvement in patient outcomes should be further reviewed.”

ICDs are small, battery-powered devices implanted in the chests of those at risk for sudden cardiac arrest. If the device detects a dangerous change in heart rhythm, it issues an electrical shock or other therapy to restore a normal heartbeat.

Patients remain conscious throughout most of an ICD implantation procedure, except for a brief period when doctors test the device by shocking the patient, which can be painful and requires deeper sedation.

“Deep sedation is not without complications,” Abdel-Hafez said. “However, there should be better selection of cases that need an anesthesiologist’s services. The CMS requirement was a blanket policy that covered all patients.”

A study from the same research team showed ICD implantation procedures that last longer in duration or that involve specific types of devices, such as biventricular ICDs, have a higher rate of sedation-related complications. Abdel-Hafez said having an anesthesiologist perform the sedation in such cases would make sense. Differentiating between higher- and lower-risk procedures could help improve patient outcomes without imposing unnecessary cost burdens, he added.

The researchers reviewed 431 ICD implants performed at Indiana University Health - Methodist Hospital. Just more than half (243) were performed before the February 2010 policy change; 188 were performed after. After the policy change, patients spent an extra day in the hospital (on average, four days instead of three) and incurred an additional $844 in medical charges per case for a total of $158,000 in additional costs overall.

The study was self-funded by the Indiana University School of Medicine.

For more information: www.acc.org

Related Content

Acutus Medical, AcQMap High Resolution Imaging and Mapping System, improvement over sCT

Image courtesy of Acutus Medical

News | EP Mapping and Imaging Systems| October 06, 2015
Acutus Medical, a global heart rhythm technology company, presented data that show the AcQMap High Resolution Imaging...
News | Heart Failure| October 02, 2015
Cyberonics Inc. announced results from the extension of the ANTHEM-HF clinical study (ENCORE Study). Results of the...
AtriCure, cryoFORM cryoablation probe, launch
Technology | Ablation Systems| October 02, 2015
AtriCure Inc. launched the cryoFORM cryoablation probe, which offers increased probe flexibility to adapt to a variety...
predicting arrhythmias, mcgill university, alternans patterns
News | EP Lab| September 28, 2015
Researchers have discovered how to predict some cardiac arrhythmias several steps before they even occur. It’s a...
ACC, atrial fibrillation registries, ablation, left atrial appendage occlusion procedures, LAAO Registry
News | Atrial Fibrillation| September 24, 2015
The American College of Cardiology (ACC) launched two new clinical registry programs in August to track real-world...
Biotronik, NORDIC ICD trial, defibrillation testing, DF testing, shock efficacy
News | Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICD)| September 24, 2015
Biotronik announced the publication of NORDIC ICD (NO Regular Defibrillation testing In Cardioverter-Defibrillator...
guideline, treating supraventricular tachycardia, ACC, AHA, HRS
News | EP Lab| September 23, 2015
A new guideline aimed at helping clinicians treat patients with supraventricular tachycardia, or a rapid heart rate,...
MedLumics, OCT, real-time assessment, catheter ablation, atrial fibrillation
Feature | EP Mapping and Imaging Systems| September 17, 2015
MedLumics has announced the completion of a successful single-case pre-clinical feasibility study of its optical...
Texas Cardiac Arrhythmia Institute, TCAI, first in United States, EpiAccess System, epicardial ablation

Image courtesy of EpiEP

News | Ablation Systems| September 15, 2015
The Texas Cardiac Arrhythmia Institute (TCAI) at St. David's Medical Center recently became the first facility in the...
Medtronic, Evera, ICD, MR-conditional, MRI, FDA approval
Technology | Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICD)| September 14, 2015
Medtronic received the first U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval for an implantable cardioverter...
Overlay Init