Feature | Pacemakers | March 22, 2017

Closed Loop Stimulation Pacemaker Programing Reduces Syncope

SPAIN trial meets primary endpoint of reduction in recurrent fainting episodes

closed loop stimulation, DDD-CLS, ACC17, SPAIN trial
closed loop stimulation, DDD-CLS, ACC17, SPAIN trial

March 22, 2017 — Patients with recurrent fainting episodes (syncope) who received a pacemaker delivering a pacing program designed to detect and stop the abnormal heart rhythms that precede syncope, had a seven-fold reduction in syncope compared with patients in a placebo pacing group. These were the findings of the SPAIN trial, presented at the American College of Cardiology (ACC) 2017 Annual Scientific Session. 

The study is the first prospective double-blind, placebo-controlled trial to show robustly positive results for the pacing program known as closed loop stimulation (DDD-CLS). It was used in patients with recurrent syncope. The trial met its primary endpoint of a significant reduction in fainting episodes with DDD-CLS compared to placebo pacing. 

“Our study showed up to a seven-fold reduction in recurrences of syncope” in patients who used the DDD-CLS program, said Gonzalo Baron-Esquivias, M.D., Ph.D., FESC, associate professor, chief of the clinical cardiology section and head of studies in the cardiology department at Virgen del Rocio University Hospital in Seville, Spain, and the study’s lead author. 

This study is important, he said, because of the lack of available treatments for recurrent syncope. 

“Now a door is open and we have a new possible treatment for these patients,” he said. 

Syncope is triggered by a sudden drop in blood pressure and heart rate, which in turn reduces blood flow to the brain. While episodes of syncope are not fatal, they can be very dangerous due to loss of consciousness and can severely affect patients’ quality of life. About half of all women and one-third of men will experience syncope in their lifetime. The real concern, Baron-Esquivias said, is that for many, these episodes will recur and they aren’t predictable. 

Pacemakers are widely used to treat other heart-rhythm disorders, particularly an abnormally slow heart beat (bradycardia). In DDD-CLS pacing for recurrent syncope, the pacemaker detects contractions or spasms in the heart muscle that typically occur before an episode of syncope and releases an electrical signal that calms the heart down, preventing sudden dips in heart rate and blood pressure. Earlier small trials of DDD-CLS had shown mixed results in preventing fainting episodes. 

In the SPAIN trial, Baron-Esquivias and his colleagues recruited 54 patients aged 40 or older from 12 medical centers in Spain and Canada. All had experienced more than five episodes of syncope in their lifetimes, with more than two in the past year. To be eligible, participants had to have normal results on an electrocardiogram, echocardiogram, 24-hour Holter test, carotid sinus massage and orthostatic test. They also had to show a drop in blood pressure and heart rate on a test in which the head rapidly changes position. 

All participants were implanted with a pacemaker. The researchers randomly assigned half to receive DDD-CLS pacing for 12 months and the other half to a pacing program called DDI, which does not respond to the contractions in the heart that precede syncope and, therefore, functioned in the SPAIN trial as a placebo program. After 12 months, the two programs were switched so that the patients who had received DDD-CLS during the first year received DDI for the next 12 months, and vice versa. If a patient in either group had more than three episodes of syncope in one month, their pacing assignment was switched. Patients and their doctors were blinded at all times to their group assignment. 

Forty-six patients completed the trial, which lasted two years. The patients’ average age was 56, and 48 percent of them were men. During the trial, four patients experienced syncope while receiving DDD-CLS pacing, compared with 21 patients who fainted during DDI pacing, a statistically significant difference. 

Among patients initially assigned to DDD-CLS, 72.2 percent saw a reduction of more than 50 percent in syncope episodes within the first year, but fainting recurred after they crossed over to the DDI group. Patients who crossed over to DDD-CLS after a year of placebo pacing saw a reduction of more than 50 percent in syncope episodes during the second year. Nine patients who initially received DDI pacing met the criterion for early crossover to DDD-CLS during the first year. The estimated time to a first syncope episode was longer among patients receiving DDD-CLS –– 29 months compared with just over nine months for patients receiving DDI, a statistically significant difference. 

Limitations of the study are its small size and short duration of follow-up (two years), Baron-Esquivias said. 

Baron-Esquivias, who currently uses DDD-CLS pacing to treat patients with recurrent syncope in his own practice, said that if these findings are confirmed by larger, ongoing studies, such as the ongoing BioSync CLS trial sponsored by Biotronic, he expects that international guidelines will be changed to recommend DDD-CLS pacing in these patients. 

The trial was funded by the Investigation Agency of the Spanish Society of Cardiology, which received an unrestricted grant from Biotronik Spain. Biotronik is the developer of the DDD-CLS program.

Find out more information on CLS programing. 

Related Content

Low-Dose ‘Triple Pill’ Lowers Blood Pressure More Than Usual Care
News | ACC | March 20, 2018
March 20, 2018 — A pill combining low doses of three...
Managing Blood Pressure in Barbershops Yields Substantial Improvements

Image from presentation, "A Cluster-Randomized Trial of Blood-Pressure Reduction in Black Barbershops," Victor et al

News | ACC | March 20, 2018
March 20, 2018 — African-American men who received medical intervention aimed at controlling their...
Trial Bolsters Evidence in Favor of Closing Hole in Heart After Stroke
News | ACC | March 20, 2018
March 20, 2018 — Among people with a type of hole in the heart, known as patent foramen ovale (PFO), those who receiv
Aspirin Lowers Risk of Death for Patients with Diabetes, Heart Failure
News | ACC | March 15, 2018
March 15, 2018 — For people living with both Type 2 diabetes and heart failure, taking an...
ECG on Smartwatch Accurately Detects AFib
News | ACC | March 15, 2018
March 15, 2018 – A newly-designed wristband and corresponding app that works with a smartwatch can accurately display
Breastfeeding May Have Long-Term Heart Health Benefits for Some Moms
News | ACC | March 15, 2018
March 15, 2018 — Women with norm
Alirocumab Reduces Cardiovascular Events after Acute Coronary Syndrome
News | ACC | March 13, 2018
March 13, 2018 –  Among patients with persistently high cholesterol despite high-intensity statin therapy, the propro
Wearable Defibrillator Cuts Overall Mortality, But Not Sudden Deaths After Heart Attack

Jeffrey Olgin, M.D., F.A.C.C., Division of Cardiology, UCSF

On behalf of VEST investigators 

News | ACC | March 13, 2018
March 13, 2018 –  Wearing a lightweight vest equipped with a cardioverter...
Overlay Init