Feature | April 16, 2014| Dave Fornell

Federal Court Orders Injunction on U.S. Sales of Medtronic CoreValve

Medtronic plans to appeal court ruling

Corevalve beats surgery, ACC 2014, TAVR vs surgery, Edwards lawsuit
April 16, 2014 — The U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware granted a preliminary injunction limiting the sale of Medtronic's CoreValve transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) system in the United States. The court ordered the injunction April 10, which will go into effect the Week of April 21. 
 
At Medtronic's request, the Federal District Court agreed to postpone the implementation of the order for seven business days to allow Medtronic to seek prompt relief from the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals. Medtronic is appealing the court's injunction, and intends to ask the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals to prevent it from going into effect until it determines if the injunction was properly issued. 
 
The decision stems from a federal jury decision in 2010 that CoreValve willfully infringed on patent use for the Edwards Lifesciences Corp. U.S. Andersen transcatheter aortic valve replacement patent. 
 
At the conclusion of the hearing, Chief Judge Gregory Sleet ordered Edwards and Medtronic to confer on what instances the CoreValve device could continue to be used in the treatment of U.S. patients at centers currently trained on CoreValve. The companies are to agree on a mechanism that will enable physicians at facilities currently trained on CoreValve to make a clinical judgment as to which device to implant (CoreValve or the Edwards’ Sapien device) free from the limitations of the injunction. The court stated that CoreValve is a “safer device, and that patients in whom it is implanted have better outcomes with a lower risk of death.” 
 
Medtronic said the ruling has no impact on the sale or marketing of CoreValve outside of the United States or the use of CoreValve in the current U.S. clinical trials.
 
Edwards initiated this case in 2008. On April 1, 2010, a federal jury found Medtronic willfully infringed Edwards' U.S. Andersen patent and awarded damages. In November 2012, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the jury decision. In October 2013, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Medtronic's appeal.
 
The patent involved in this suit is part of the Andersen family of patents. The U.S. Andersen patent was issued in 1995. A petition has been filed with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to extend this patent into early 2016. In a separate case, a federal jury in January found that Medtronic CoreValve had willfully infringed Edwards' U.S. Cribier transcatheter heart valve patent, and awarded damages to Edwards in that trial.
 
The Edwards’ Sapien TAVR system was the first to gain U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) clearance in November 2011. The Medtronic CoreValve gained FDA approval this past January as the second TAVR device on the U.S. market. Many observers view the lawsuits by Edwards as a way to prevent competition in the U.S. market, similar to the suits and counter suits involved with drug-eluting stent manufactures in the United States over the past decade. Edwards filed similar suits in Europe after both valves gained market clearance there. Those suits have been ongoing for years.
 
The CoreValve System received FDA approval in January for patients at extreme risk for surgical valve replacement. Prior to that date, CoreValve therapy was available to extreme risk patients who were eligible to participate in the U.S. clinical trial. The CoreValve System is not yet approved in the U.S. for other patient groups.
 
In clinical trial data, the CoreValve appears to have better outcomes than that of the Sapien valve. At the American College of Cardiology (ACC) annual meeting in March, late-breaking trial data stated that the CoreValve actually out-performed surgical valve replacement despite the inexperience of the CoreValve operators with the device. The CoreValve U.S. pivotal high-risk patient trial showed the Medtronic self-expanding CoreValve device had a 26 percent survival benefit above the surgical valve implant patients. In the same patient population, the Edwards Sapien was found to be equal to surgery, but was not superior to surgery.
 
For more information: www.edwards.com, www.medtronic.com
 

Related Content

Henry Ford Hospital First in Michigan to Perform Cardioband Mitral Valve Procedure

An angiography image showing the catheter-based implantation of the Cardioband annuloplasty ring using corkscrew shaped anchors.

News | Heart Valve Technology | June 13, 2018
Henry Ford Hospital is one of 17 U.S. trial sites using a catheter-based procedure approved in Europe to repair a leaky...
Abbott Portico transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) performed well PORTICO I real-world study. #EuroPCR
News | Heart Valve Technology | June 01, 2018
June 1, 2018 –  Use of the Abbott Portico transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) therapy was associated with e
Tendyne Transcatheter Mitral Valve Replacement Device Demonstrates Positive 30-Day Outcomes
News | Heart Valve Technology | May 25, 2018
Abbott announced favorable outcomes from the first 100 patients treated in a global study of its Tendyne Transcatheter...
A 3-D printed aortic root with an simulated implant of an Edwards Sapien TAVR valve. New clinical data points to length-of-stay as a new predictor of outcomes in TAVR patients. Image from Henry Ford Hospital.

A 3-D printed aortic root with an simulated implant of an Edwards Sapien TAVR valve. New clinical data points to length-of-stay as a new predictor of outcomes in TAVR patients. Image from Henry Ford Hospital. 

Feature | Heart Valve Technology | May 14, 2018
May 14, 2018 – A new study finds patients who stay in the hospital for more than 72 hours when undergoing trans-femor
The use of 3-D printed hearts from patients' pre-TAVR planning CT scans have improved outcomes of procedures at the University of Minnesota. Clearly identifying where calcium is located on the valves prior to TAVR device implantation has helped reduce the incidence of paravalvular leak.  #SCAI, #SCAI2018

The use of 3-D printed hearts from patients' pre-TAVR planning CT scans have improved outcomes of procedures at the University of Minnesota. Clearly identifying where calcium is located on the valves prior to TAVR device implantation has helped reduce the incidence of paravalvular leak.

News | Heart Valve Technology | May 14, 2018
May 14, 2018 – A new study examines the effectiveness of 3-D printing technology and computer modeling to predict par
First-Ever Risk Tool Helps Predict TAVR Readmission Rates in 2018 SCAI late-breaking study. #SCAI, #SCAI2018
News | Heart Valve Technology | May 11, 2018
A new study looked at the effectiveness of a novel risk tool to predict 30-day readmission rates in patients undergoing...
Medtronic Shares Two-Year Harmony Transcatheter Pulmonary Valve Results at SCAI 2018. #SCAI, #SCAI2018
News | Heart Valve Technology | May 11, 2018
Medtronic plc announced two-year outcomes for the Harmony Transcatheter Pulmonary Valve (TPV) from its early...
Colibri Heart Valve Continues Enrollment in TAVI Early Feasibility Study
News | Heart Valve Technology | May 07, 2018
Colibri Heart Valve LLC announced the Colibri transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) System has been used on an...
An 3D echo view of a Neovasc Tiara transcatheter mitral valve. This valve is currently in clinical trials and is ahead of most of the TMVR devices in development.

A 3-D echo view of a Neovasc Tiara transcatheter mitral valve. This valve is currently in clinical trials and is ahead of most of the TMVR devices in development.

Feature | Heart Valve Technology | May 04, 2018 | Dave Fornell, Editor
May 4, 2018 — Transcatheter val...
Edwards Granted CE Mark For First Transcatheter Tricuspid Therapy - Cardioband Tricuspid Valve Reconstruction System
News | Heart Valve Technology | May 01, 2018
Edwards Lifesciences Corp.announced that it received CE Mark for the Edwards Cardioband Tricuspid Valve Reconstruction...
Overlay Init