News | Cardiovascular Business | May 05, 2021

Avoiding High-risk Cath Lab Procedures Does Not Necessarily Improve Hospital Scores

Study looked at hospital-level PCI performance with simulated risk avoidance strategies

Avoiding high-risk PCI procedures does not improve hospital scores according to a study presented at SCAI 2021. CTO procedure at Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit. Photo by Dave Fornell.

Avoiding high-risk PCI procedures does not improve hospital scores according to a study presented at SCAI 2021. CTO procedure at Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit. Photo by Dave Fornell.


May 5, 2021 — A late-breaking study presented at the Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions (SCAI) 2021 meeting looked at hospital-level percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) performance with simulated risk avoidance strategies and found this might not improve performance. 

"Any individual hospital seeking to improve their performance, there is no guarantee that practicing systematic risk-avoidance will improve the measured quality of a PCI program, and may in fact worsen it," explained Ashwin Nathan M.D., a cardiology fellow at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, who presented the study.

He said the study data support offering PCI to appropriate candidates regardless of calculated pre-procedural risk.

The study was conducted because it is believed some PCI operators may avoid high-risk cases so they can to limit the effect of these cases on performance metrics. Nathan said the effect of such a strategy on individual hospital performance metrics is uncertain. This study simulated the effects of systematic risk avoidance on risk-adjusted post-PCI mortality.

He said hospitals, especially in states that require public reporting on outcomes, may shy away from high-risk patients or complex procedures in an effort to improve these publicly reported scores. 

Researchers identified all adult patients who underwent PCI at a participating hospital in the National Cardiovascular Data Registry CathPCI registry between January 2017 and December 2017. Risk-adjusted mortality rates were calculated for each hospital. They then simulated a systematic risk-avoidance strategy of eliminating the highest predicted risk cases (top 10%) for each hospital, then recalculating risk-adjusted mortality rates.

The study included 1,565 hospitals in the analysis. Of these, 883 (56.4%) hospitals reduced their risk-adjusted mortality rate, but 610 (39%) hospitals increased their risk-adjusted mortality rate. Hospitals changed their risk-adjusted mortality rate by -0.14% on average with this strategy. 

There were no significant differences in the patient or procedural characteristics among hospitals which improved compared with those that worsened.

The study authors included: Ashwin Nathan, M.D.; Sameed Khatana, M.D., MPH; Elias Dayoub, M.D., MPP; Lauren Eberly, M.D., MPH; Paul Fiorilli, M.D.; Alexander Fanaroff, M.D.; Peter Groeneveld, M.D., MS; and Jay S. Giri, M.D., FSCAI, all from the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania. Stephen Waldo, M.D., University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus; Robert W. Yeh, M.D., FSCAI, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center; Sunil V. Rao, M.D., FSCAI, and Adam Nelson, MBBS, Duke University Hospital; and Pratik Manandhar, MS, Daniel Wojdyla, Ph.D., and Tracy Yu-Ping Wang, M.D., from the Duke Clinical Research Institute.

Watch the VIDEO: Avoiding Higher Risk Cath Lab Patients May Not Improve Outcomes Scores — Interview with Ashwin Nathan M.D.
 

Find more news from the SCAI 2021 virtual meeting


Related Content

News | Cardiovascular Business

September 21, 2023 — Many of the nation’s most prominent cardiovascular organizations, representing tens of thousands of ...

Home September 21, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

September 15, 2023 — The American College of Cardiology (ACC) has recognized five Hackensack Meridian Health hospitals ...

Home September 15, 2023
Home
Feature | Cardiovascular Business | By Emily Gilbert and Kamran Zamanian, PhD

The global interventional cardiology device market is driven by the number of procedures performed across the globe. The ...

Home September 12, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

September 11, 2023 — The Heart Rhythm Society (HRS) is gearing up for its second annual HRX event, bringing ...

Home September 11, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

September 11, 2023 — Elucid, Inc., a leading medical technology company providing physicians with AI-powered imaging ...

Home September 11, 2023
Home
Feature | Cardiovascular Business | By Melinda Taschetta-Millane

As we wind down the summer months, DAIC takes a look at the Top 10 most-read pieces of content from www.dicardiology.com ...

Home August 31, 2023
Home
Feature | Cardiovascular Business

August 22, 2023 — Leaders at University Hospitals (UH) Harrington Heart & Vascular Institute are saddened to share news ...

Home August 22, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

August 17, 2023 — MemorialCare, a prominent nonprofit Southern California integrated health system, announced today that ...

Home August 17, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

August 10, 2023 — It is the position of SCAI that ABIM diplomates who successfully pass their exams and report ...

Home August 10, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

August 2, 2023 — Dr. Doria Scortichini, MD FACC joins the growing Auburn Heart Institute that is affiliated with Auburn ...

Home August 02, 2023
Home
Subscribe Now