News | Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy Devices (CRT) | September 03, 2015

Most CRT-P Patients Would Not Benefit From Addition of Defibrillator

CeRtiTuDe study findings support reducing rates of CRT-D implantation, decreasing costs and device-related complications

CeRtiTuDe cohort study, cardiac resynchronization therapy, CRT-D, CRT-P, ESC 2015

September 3, 2015 — Most patients with a cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) pacemaker would not benefit from the addition of a defibrillator, according to results from the CeRtiTuDe cohort study presented at the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Congress.

“The choice between CRT with (CRT-D) or without (CRT-P) a defibrillator remains a contentious issue,” said Prof. Jean-Yves Le Heuzey, cardiologist at Georges Pompidou Hospital, René Descartes University in Paris, France. “No randomized clinical trial has been conducted to guide this choice.”

Patients with congestive heart failure are at high risk of dying from sudden cardiac death. Over the last decade, CRT and implantable cardioverter defibrillators (ICDs) have markedly improved prognosis. Guidelines do not make firm recommendations on the choice of CRT-P versus CRT-D, stating that there is insufficient evidence from randomized controlled trials to show that CRT-D would additionally improve survival compared to CRT-P. This has left room for physician discretion and resulted in wide variation in worldwide implantation rates. For instance, the proportion of CRT implantations which are CRT-D reaches more than 90 percent in the United States whereas it is lesser across Europe.

“Whether such a high rate of CRT-D use over CRT-P is justified is an important question to answer in terms of significant costs and device-related complications,” said Le Heuzey. “ICD lead failures, inappropriate shocks and risk of infection are real problems with impacts on quality of life and possibly survival. But the ideal way to answer this question, a randomized controlled trial directly comparing CRT-P to CRT-D, would have to be large, expensive and is unlikely to ever be conducted.”

The CeRtiTuDe study evaluated the characteristics of CRT-P versus CRT-D patients in a real-world scenario and analyzed to what extent CRT-P patients would have benefited from the presence of a back-up defibrillator. It was a multicenter prospective follow-up cohort study that enrolled a total of 1,705 consecutive patients implanted with a CRT (CRT-P 535; CRT-D 1 170) between 2008 and 2010 in France. Adjudication for causes of death was conducted at two years follow-up.

Patients with CRT-P compared to CRT-D (Figure 1) were older (75.9 vs 65.6 years, p<0.0001), less often male (69.5 vs 80.8 percent, p<0.0001), more symptomatic (proportion of NYHA class III/IV, 88 vs 80 percent, p=0.002), with less coronary artery disease (40.7 vs 49.3 percent, p=0.003), wider QRS (161 ± 29 vs 155 ± 26 msec, p=0.002), more atrial fibrillation (38.7 vs 22.1 percent, p<0.0001) and more comorbidities (≥ 2 comorbidities 16.9 vs 12.9 percent, p=0.04).

At two-year follow-up 270 patients had died, giving an annual overall mortality rate of 77.9 per 1,000. The crude mortality rate among CRT-P patients was double compared to CRT-D (relative risk [RR]=1.96, 95 percent confidence interval [CI]=1.51-2.66). “By cause-of-death analysis, a large proportion of the excess mortality among CRT-P subjects was related to an increase of non-sudden death,” said Le Heuzey. “This could indicate that this excess mortality is due to heart failure and non-cardiovascular events.”

He concluded: “Our findings suggest that patients selected for CRT-P in routine clinical practice would not benefit from the addition of a defibrillator. This indicates that CRT-D rates could be reduced, with consequent decreases in costs and device-related complications.”

For more information: www.escardio.org

Related Content

A key slide from Elnabawi's presentation, showing cardiac CT plaque evaluations, showing the impact of psoriasis medication on coronary plaques at baseline and one year of treatment. It shows a reversal of vulnerable plaque development. #SCAI, #SCAI2018

A key slide from Elnabawi's presentation, showing cardiac CT plaque evaluations, showing the impact of psoriasis medication on coronary plaques at baseline and one year of treatment. It shows a reversal of vulnerable plaque development.  

Feature | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | May 14, 2018
May 14, 2018 – New clinical evidance shows common therapy options for psoriasis (PSO), a chronic inflammatory skin di
Intravenous Drug Use is Causing Rise in Heart Valve Infections, Healthcare Costs. #SCAI, #SCAI2018
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | May 14, 2018
May 14, 2018 — The opioid drug epidemic is impacting cardiology, with a new study finding the number of patients hosp
Patient Enrollment Completed in U.S. IDE Study of THERMOCOOL SMARTTOUCH SF Catheter
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | March 15, 2018
March 15, 2018 –  Johnson & Johnson Medical Devices Companies announced today that Biosense Webster, Inc., who wo
Lexington Begins HeartSentry Clinical Trial
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | February 20, 2018
February 20, 2018 – Lexington Biosciences, Inc., a development-stage medical device company, announced the commenceme
Endologix Completes Patient Enrollment in the ELEVATE IDE Clinical Study
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | February 06, 2018
February 6, 2018 – Endologix, a developer and marketer of treatments for aortic disorders, announced the completion o
12-Month Results from Veryan Medical's MIMICS-2 IDE Study Presented at LINC
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | February 01, 2018
February 1, 2018 – Thomas Zeller (Bad Krozingen, Germany) presented the 12-month results from Veryan Medical’s MIMICS
LimFlow Completes U.S. Feasibility Study Enrollment, Receives FDA Device Status
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | February 01, 2018
February 1, 2018 –  LimFlow SA, developer of minimally-inv
ESC 2017 late breaking trial hot line study presentations.
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | September 12, 2017
September 12, 2017 – The European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Congress 2017 includes several Hot Line Late-breaking C
U.K., NHS studies, weekend effect, hospital admission, atrial fibrillation, heart failure
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | June 28, 2016
New research shows patients admitted to National Health Service (NHS) hospitals in the United Kingdom for atrial...
stroke risk
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies | August 28, 2015
Most people assume strokes only happen to octogenarians, but recent evidence suggests that survivors of childhood can
Overlay Init