News | December 09, 2009

Survey Shows Alarming Implications of CMS Echocardiography Cuts

December 9, 2009 – Of the 1,200 cardiologists and cardiovascular ultrasound technicians recently surveyed, 87 percent said the new 2010 CMS Physician Fee Schedule (PFS) could force them to stop accepting Medicare patients, reduce staff or shut down their practice completely.

The American Society of Echocardiography (ASE) released the initial results of its survey about the impact of the cuts on patients and practices. ASE said the cuts could ultimately reduce patient access to echocardiography and other vital services.

“The negative effects of these cuts are immeasurable and numerous,” said Leeanne Etchison, MA, RDCS, an Indiana-based cardiac sonographer. “If fully implemented, the result will be delays in service, higher hospital admissions and probably more deaths due to undiagnosed heart conditions.”

“On many occasions we will do an urgent echo immediately following an evaluation, saving the patient’s time and alleviating the anxiety of uncertainty about a serious heart condition,” said Heriberto Gutierrez, M.D., of Desert Cardiology of Tucson. “With these proposed cuts, this same-day service will not be available, thus prolonging the diagnosis.”

Sixty-three percent of the respondents serve a patient population in which more than half are reimbursed by Medicare Part B. Almost a third of respondents provide services in an area that is rural, medically underserved or both, and the nearest provider of echocardiography services for 74 percent of the respondents is a hospital.

“If private practices close their doors because they can no longer afford to provide these services, patients will be forced to go to the hospital,” said Ben Byrd, M.D., advocacy chair of ASE. “This could be a life or death situation for Medicare patients, especially those in rural areas who can’t get to a hospital in a timely manner.”

The survey showed that for the echocardiography service providers affected most directly by the PFS payment cuts, the actions currently being considered most often are:

• 64 percent would delay the purchase of echo equipment
• 56 percent would lay off sonographers or other staff
• 53 percent would reduce staff salaries
• 47 percent might reduce staff benefits, such as 401K programs or healthcare
• 23 percent would refrain from accepting Medicare patients for any services
• 19 percent are considering closing a satellite office(s) or have already closed a satellite office(s) - 60 percent of these are located in rural areas

For those echocardiography service providers who will be indirectly affected by the payment cuts (those who receive payment through the Hospital Outpatient Payment System), the survey showed anticipated outcomes would include:

• Increased workload (74 percent)
• Longer wait times for patients (67 percent)
• Lengthened turnaround time for reports (44 percent)
• Increased overtime for staff or the need to hire additional cardiac sonographers (43 percent)

ASE collected regional anecdotes from almost 200 members who will be affected by the cuts. Many provided examples of patients who might have died had in-office echocardiography services not been available.

For more information: SeeMyHeart.org.

Related Content

New Guideline Published for Evaluation of Valvular Regurgitation After Catheter-based Valve Interventions
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | April 30, 2019
A new document compiled by four cardiac imaging professional societies provides a resource to guide clinicians in best...
Ebit and DiA Imaging Analysis Partner on AI-based Cardiac Ultrasound Analysis
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | April 16, 2019
DiA Imaging Analysis has partnered with the Italian healthcare IT company Ebit (Esaote Group), to offer DiA’s LVivo...
DiA Imaging Analysis Introduces LVivo SAX Ultrasound Analysis Tool
Technology | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | April 09, 2019
DiA Imaging Analysis announced the launch of LVivo SAX, a cardiac analysis tool that helps clinicians quickly and...
 The ScImage cloud-based PICOM365 enterprise cardiology is one of the newer generation echo reporting solutions that offers several ways to streamline workflow.

 The ScImage cloud-based PICOM365 enterprise cardiology is one of the newer generation echo reporting solutions that offers several ways to streamline workflow.

Feature | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | April 08, 2019 | Dave Fornell, Editor
Echocardiography reporting systems are usually integrated with, or offered as an add-on module for a ...
Echocardiograms May Help With Patient Selection for Transcatheter Mitral Valve Repair
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | March 21, 2019
Clinicians should use echocardiography when determining whether patients with heart failure and a leaking heart valve...
Epsilon Launches EchoInsight Pro Starter Configuration
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | February 15, 2019
Epsilon Imaging recently launched the new EchoInsight Pro Starter configuration for those programs that may be budget...
A view of GE Healthcare's volume max, or Vmax, which allows for nearly triple the frame rate speeds on 3-D TEE in a single beat over previous generation systems.

A view of GE Healthcare's volume max, or Vmax, which allows for nearly triple the frame rate speeds on 3-D TEE in a single beat over previous-generation systems.  

Feature | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | January 31, 2019 | Dave Fornell, Editor
The higher expense and lower frame rates of 3-D...
ASE Releases New Guide to Performing Comprehensive Transthoracic Echo Exams
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound | January 21, 2019
January 21, 2019 – Medical experts have released “...
Overlay Init