Feature | October 29, 2008| Dave Fornell

Fluoro X-Ray Exposure Needs to Rely on Facts, Not Opinions, Reader Says

There is skepticism among cardiologists whether flat panel detectors can help lower the X-ray dose more than using traditional image intensifiers in the cath lab. There was a story concerning this in the last issue of DAIC which said flat panel detectors are replacing image intensifiers partly because they help lower the X-ray exposure to patients.

This prompted a letter to the editor from John K. Grady, PE, principal owner of Grady Research Inc., which specializes in the design, manufacture, sale and service of interventional imaging systems. He previously owned the XRE Corp., which designed and built cardiac catheterization imaging equipment for most of the major suppliers on a private-label basis. He’s the sort of guy who might know a little more about these systems than me or the average Joe cardiologist.

He wrote, “For what it is worth, testing a flat panel on digital subtraction angiography (DSA) as the article has reported on, has no relevance at all to flat panel dose on fluoro, which is the major source of dose in interventional procedures. DSA is inherently a high dose procedure... Flat panels unequivocally have about two-times higher dose then II tubes (image intensifiers) on fluoro. This is due to known inherent high electrical noise. This has been proven in the field by comparison studies in Germany and now Australia... and is well known from the physics of the devices, published and discussed at the International Society for Optical Engineering (SPIE). Same case type, same time for procedure – two times more. That is what needs to be reported, not anecdotal stories about what an M.D. using any particular brand thinks about it.”

Grady went on to say this is an example of misperceptions propagated by salesmen for the device manufacturers. “Such scientific studies overrule opinions of individual M.D.’s who mostly listen to salesmen, who in turn reassure them about low dose,” he argued.

In his experience, Grady said the flat panels he has measured are set up for 4-5 uR (micro Roentgens) per frame on fluoro, whereas II tubes were routinely set up at 2-2.5 uR per frame. He said typically the amount entering the image forming detector and leaving the patient is only about 1 percent of the radiation entering the patient (99 percent is absorbed), but that latter observation varies widely with patient size. Higher X-ray doses are used in radiography, DSA, angiography and mammography to cut noise, 10 to 100 times more per frame as fluoro, but for a shorter duration, he said.

“That is what is needed to be published - the specific input uR per frame on fluoro, which correlates directly to patient dose, and has no opinion aspect to it,” Grady said.

Since the story Mr. Grady refers to included GE products, I asked GE’s Interventional Clinical Development Manager Barry Belanger his opinion. He wrote, “John Grady is correct in saying there are published reports of higher fluoro doses with flat panel detectors than with II’s. However, in the mid 1980s, GE recognized that major efforts would be required to make their flat panel detectors at least as dose efficient for fluoro operation as conventional II-based systems. That’s why GE made a huge effort to minimize noise sources on its proprietary panel designs, and opted for a more challenging, proprietary integrated readout electronics design incorporating one analog to digital converter for each readout column of the panel to minimize electronic noise. The result is that GE’s flat panel detectors have the highest fluoro DQE values in the industry.”

Related Content

Stereotaxis, Niobe remote magnetic navigation system, Philips Allura Xper FD10 cardiovascular X-ray, interface, integration
News | Robotic Systems| January 20, 2017
Stereotaxis Inc. announced the release of an interface between its remote magnetic navigation system for...
Arterys, Cardiac MRI, cardiac MRI advances

An example of the Arterys blood flow imaging assessment software that can help automate cardiac MRI. 

Feature | Cardiac Imaging| January 16, 2017 | Dave Fornell
Each year imaging system manufacturers use the Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) meeting at the end of the
Whale Imaging, G-Arm Duo, mobile C-arm, FDA clearance, launch, RSNA 2017
Technology | Mobile C-Arms| January 09, 2017
Whale Imaging Inc. announced U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 510(k) clearance of the G-Arm Duo. The Duo is the...
Sponsored Content | Videos | Cardiac Imaging| January 06, 2017
ITN and DAIC Editor Dave Fornell takes a tour of some of the most innovative new technologies being displayed on the
Siemens artis pheno angiography system
Technology | Angiography| January 04, 2017
January 4, 2015 — At RSNA 2016, Siemens Healthineers unveiled its 510(k)-pending robot-supported Artis pheno angiogra
Sponsored Content | Videos | Radiation Dose Management| December 19, 2016
Mahadevappa Mahesh, MS, Ph.D., chief physicist and professor of radiology and radiological science at Johns Hopkins H
Sponsored Content | Videos | Angiography| December 07, 2016
Shimadzu's latest generation interventional lab angiography imaging system, the Trinias, enables advanced imaging cap
Siemens Healthineers, PURE Platform, angiography, EVAR, CTO, RSNA 2016
News | Angiography| December 07, 2016
December 7, 2016 — At the 102nd Scientific Assembly and Annual Meeting of the Radiological Society of North America (
Ziehm Imaging, RSNA 2016, mobile C-arms, CMOS digital flat panel detectors, Ziehm Solo FD
Technology | Mobile C-Arms| November 27, 2016
November 27, 2016 — At the 2016 Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) annual meeting, Ziehm Imaging presents i
Infinix-i Sky +, RSNA 2016, Toshiba, angiography systems

Toshiba Medical’s Infinix-i product line, including the Infinix-i Sky +, delivers patient access, image quality and safety features for virtually any image-guided procedure, including those in hybrid OR settings.

News | Angiography| November 21, 2016
November 21, 2016 – Healthcare providers seeking versatile imaging technology for their angiography needs can find a
Overlay Init