Feature | April 10, 2013

Little to No Physician Work Efficiencies Exist When Different Providers Interpret Different Imaging Scans on the Same Patient

New study find Medicare estimates of potential work savings are greatly exaggerated


April 10, 2013 — According to a new study published online in the Journal of the American College of Radiology, any efficiencies in physician interpretation and diagnosis gained when different providers interpret different medical imaging scans performed on the same patient are minute and vary by procedure.

Specifically, no potential intra-service work duplication was found when different exam interpretations were rendered by different physicians in the same group practice. Small potential efficiencies were found possible regarding pre- and post-service activities. Across all modalities, this corresponds to a maximum Medicare professional component physician fee reduction of only 0.95 percent to 1.87 percent for services regarding the same type of scan. For services from different modalities, potential duplications were too small to even quantify.

This issue is debated in health policy circles because the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) recently enacted a 25 percent Multiple Procedure Payment Reduction to Medicare reimbursement for interpretation of advanced diagnostic imaging scans performed on the same patient in the same session. This reduction applies across all physicians in a group or practice. It does not affect the number of scans ordered, only interpretation of scans already performed. This type of reduction has recently been expanded to physical therapy, cardiovascular and ophthalmology technical services as well. 

“These findings are important because the exams affected are primarily used to care for the most sick or injured patients — those with massive head and body trauma, stroke or widespread cancer. These people often require interpretations by different doctors to survive. This study shows that the data Medicare used to justify funding cuts was inflated by 1,200 percent and not reflective of clinical practice,” said Geraldine McGinty, M.D., chair of the American College of Radiology Commission on Economics.

Because each imaging study produces a set of images requiring individual interpretation, a physician is ethically and professionally obligated to expend the same time and effort, regardless of the date or time of service. Studies show that medical imaging use and imaging costs are down significantly since 2006.

 “While potential efficiencies exist in physician pre- and post-service work when same-session, same-modality imaging services are rendered by different physicians in the same group practice, these are relatively minuscule, and have been grossly overestimated. These findings support the need for greater transparency and methodological rigor when healthcare regulatory actions are taken,” said McGinty.

For more information: www.acr.org

 

 


Related Content

News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

June 11, 2025 — Bayer and the Broad Institute have have extended their research collaboration of 10 years by an ...

Home June 11, 2025
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

May 27, 2025 — Despite scientific advances in cardiovascular care, people in living in rural areas and other communities ...

Home May 27, 2025
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

May 20, 2025 — Shockwave Medical, Inc., part of Johnson & Johnson MedTechhas announced the 30-day primary endpoint ...

Home May 21, 2025
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

Jan. 13, — A new cohort study among 103,642 adults found that current use of cigars was associated with increased risk ...

Home January 14, 2025
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

Nov. 22, 2024 — BridgeBio Pharma, Inc. recently announced that the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved ...

Home November 25, 2024
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

Nov. 18, 2024 — Silence Therapeutics presented end-of-treatment data from its Phase 2 ALPACAR-360 study of zerlasiran, a ...

Home November 18, 2024
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

Aug. 15, 2024 — According to a new study being presented at ACC Asia 2024 in Delhi, India, drinking over 400 mg of ...

Home August 14, 2024
Home
Videos | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

As part of DAIC's continuing Thought Leadership Series, this month Editorial Director Melinda Taschetta-Millane sits ...

Home July 30, 2024
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

July 25, 2024 — BioCardia, Inc., a global leader in cellular and cell-derived therapeutics for the treatment of ...

Home July 25, 2024
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

July 18, 2024 — Elucid, a pioneering AI medical technology company providing physicians with imaging analysis software ...

Home July 18, 2024
Home
Subscribe Now