Feature | November 08, 2012

PFO Closure May Improve Outcomes Over Medical Therapy in Cryptogenic Stroke

Results of the RESPECT trial using the Amplatzer device presented at TCT 2012

Amplatzer Structural Heart Occulder Closure Device RESPECT Clinical Trial

November 8, 2012 — A clinical trial indicates that using an investigational medical device to close a PFO, or “hole in the heart,” may be superior to medical management alone in the prevention of a repeated stroke. Results of the RESPECT trial were presented at the 24th annual Transcatheter Cardiovascular Therapeutics (TCT) scientific symposium, sponsored by the Cardiovascular Research Foundation (CRF).

A PFO (patent foramen ovale) is a flap-like opening between the left and right upper chambers of the heart, which typically fuses shut after birth. In approximately one in four people, the opening does not fuse shut, and in some cases, a blood clot may pass through the PFO and potentially travel to the brain, causing an ischemic stroke. It is estimated that PFO rates are three times higher in the patient population with cryptogenic stroke, or stroke without an overt source. However, to date, no randomized clinical trial has demonstrated superiority of PFO closure over standard medical therapy for secondary stroke prevention, despite there being observational data suggesting a possible benefit.

To see a video of this presentation, click here.

RESPECT was a prospective, randomized, multicenter trial designed to evaluate whether PFO closure with the Amplazter PFO Occluder is superior to the current standard medical treatment in the prevention of recurrent stroke. Made of wire mesh, the investigational device is inserted into the PFO through a catheter to seal the passageway between the left and right atria.

A total of 980 patients were enrolled over eight years. Patients diagnosed with a cryptogenic stroke and PFO (age 18-60) were randomized to either the investigational device group or the medical therapy group within 270 days of the stroke. Forty-nine percent of the patients had a large stroke as the qualifying stroke event. The average age in the study was 46, and patients were otherwise generally healthy.

Statistics from the RESPECT trial:

  • Two-year events rates were low in both the device and medically treated groups
    • 1.6 percent vs. 3 percent, respectively
    • All primary events were non-fatal, recurrent ischemic strokes
  • The clinical risk reduction of stroke using the device ranged from 46.6 percent to 72.7 percent compared to medical management alone, depending on the analysis population being assessed
    • Among the intent-to-treat analysis population, this reduction achieved borderline statistical significance
    • In per-protocol and as-treated analyses, the reductions were statistically significant
  • Serious adverse event rates did not differ between the device and medical groups
    • 23 percent vs. 21.6 percent, respectively
  • Medical therapy included one of four regimens:
    • Warfarin (25.2 percent)
    • Aspirin (46.5 percent)
    • Clopidogrel (14 percent)
    • Aspirin combined with dipyridamole (8.1 percent)
    • Aspirin combined with clopidogrel (6.3 percent)
  • The total incidence of atrial fibrillation was not significantly different between the device and medical group
    • 3 percent vs. 1.5 percent, respectively
  • No device-related thrombus, erosion or embolization was observed
  • There were no study-related deaths


“In patients between 18 and 60 years old with cryptogenic ischemic stroke and PFO, the totality of evidence from RESPECT demonstrates that PFO closure with the Amplatzer PFO Occluder provides evidence of benefit over medical management alone, with very low device and procedure-related risks,” said lead investigator John D. Carroll, M.D., co-director of the Cardiac and Vascular Center and director of interventional cardiology at the University of Colorado. “The optimal secondary prevention strategy following a cryptogenic ischemic stroke in patients who are found to have a PFO has been unknown. This need to know is particularly intense for young stroke patients who have no or minimal traditional risk factors for ischemic stroke, yet face a risk of recurrent stroke for many decades. RESPECT makes progress in both removing the 'unknown' or cryptogenic cause of some strokes and providing high quality data from a large, long-term randomized trial.”

The RESPECT clinical trial was sponsored by St. Jude Medical Inc., which provided research support to the University of Colorado School of Medicine.

For more information: www.crf.org

Related Content

Statins Associated With Improved Heart Structure and Function
News | Pharmaceuticals| May 26, 2017
Statins are associated with improved heart structure and function, according to research presented at EuroCMR 2017, May...
Arto System Shows Promise as Less-Invasive Therapy for Heart Failure Patients
News | Heart Failure| May 26, 2017
Recent outcomes from the MAVERIC clinical trial confirm earlier positive findings that MVRx’s Arto System safely and...
Intensive Glycemic Control Program Produces Significant Per-Patient Cost Savings for CABG Surgery
News | Cardiovascular Surgery| May 25, 2017
A new study from Emory University observed a near-20 percent reduction in perioperative complications, a 1.2-day...
Edwards Lifesciences Centera self expanding transcatheter (TAVR) valve
News | Heart Valve Technology| May 24, 2017
May 24, 2017 — Late-breaking data presented at EuroPCR 2017 demonstrating excellent clinical outcomes for...
3-D Echo Image Analysis With Philips' HeartModel A.I. is Accurate and Reproducible
News | Cardiovascular Ultrasound| May 24, 2017
May 24, 2017 — Philips recently announced the results from a global study indicating that automated...
Heart Failure Mortality Inversely Related to Wealth of Country
News | Heart Failure| May 24, 2017
Death in patients with heart failure is inversely related to the wealth of the country they live in, according to late...
Shockwave Medical Announces CE Mark for Coronary Lithoplasty System and Activities at EuroPCR 2017
News | Cath Lab| May 23, 2017
Shockwave Medical announced last week CE Mark for the company’s Coronary Lithoplasty System for the treatment of...
New Paper Highlights Success of Advanced Treatments in Complex Aortic Aneurysm Repair
News | Endovascular Aortic Repair| May 23, 2017
Significant success has been achieved in treating complex proximal aneurysms using a combination of fenestrated and...
Risk of Heart Transplant Rejection Reduced by Desensitizing Patient Antibodies
News | Cardiovascular Surgery| May 23, 2017
The risk of heart transplant rejection can be reduced by desensitizing patient antibodies, according to research...
Overlay Init