The Edwards Lifesciences Sapien 3 valve. It is designed with a skirt to prevent paravalvular leak.
Feature | March 25, 2015
Sapien 3 TAVR Device Improves 30-Day Outcomes for Major Endpoints
First report from U.S. trial of third-generation TAVR device in high- and intermediate-risk patients
March 25, 2015 — The Sapien 3 heart valve (Edwards Lifesciences) demonstrated lower death, stroke and paravalvular leak rates than earlier generation devices in patients at high risk for surgery and showed encouraging results in intermediate-risk patients, according to research presented at the 2015 American College of Cardiology (ACC) Annual Scientific Session.
Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is approved for patients with severe aortic stenosis whose health profile makes them ineligible or high-risk candidates for surgery. This trial, called PARTNER II S3, evaluated 30-day outcomes with the Sapien 3 valve, the latest modification of the balloon-expandable system used in these procedures. This is the first presentation of large-scale data for the third-generation device and the first report of outcomes in intermediate-risk patients in the United States.
In addition to the study’s 583 high-risk or inoperable patients, 1,076 intermediate-risk patients were treated with the new device. The death rate was 2.2 percent, or 13 patients, in the high-risk group and 1.1 percent, or 12 deaths, in the intermediate-risk group. Heart-related deaths accounted for 1.4 percent of the mortality in the high-risk group and 0.9 percent in the intermediate-risk group. High-risk patients had a stroke rate of 1.5 percent, 0.9 percent of them disabling; in the intermediate-risk group, those rates were 2.6 percent and 1 percent, respectively.
“The 30-day mortality rates were extremely low, stroke rates were approximately 1 percent in both groups and significant paravalvular regurgitation was rare,” said Susheel Kodali, M.D., director of the Heart Valve Center, Columbia University Medical Center/New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York City, and a co-principal investigator of the study. “Death and stroke rates have been decreasing with every modification of the Sapien system.”
Major vascular complications occurred in about 5 percent of high- and intermediate-risk patients, a reduction of two-thirds compared with the first-generation Sapien. Other clinical events also were reduced from results in previous Sapien studies, including heart attacks in 0.5 percent of patients, injury to the aortic area called annular rupture in 0.3 percent and coronary obstruction in 0.3 percent. A new permanent pacemaker was implanted in 13 percent of high-risk patients and 10 percent of intermediate-risk patients, a slightly higher rate than with earlier balloon-expandable valves.
"These results of more than 1,600 patients treated with the Sapien 3 valve demonstrate the most significant progress in the development of TAVR and the Sapien family of valves since the first PARTNER study was initiated in 2007," Kodali said."With average ages in the 80s, the high-risk and intermediate-risk patients in the study had strikingly low mortality rates of 2.2 and 1.1, respectively, despite predicted 30-day mortality that was much higher. Additionally, the rates of significant paravalvular leaks were low in both cohorts – 3.0 for high-risk and 4.2 for intermediate – which represented meaningful improvements over prior studies with earlier generation devices."
Paravalvular leak has been associated with poorer outcomes after TAVR. The third-generation model used in this study was modified with an outer skirt designed to reduce leak by sealing gaps around the valve. With the new device, 3.7 percent of patients had moderate leak and 0.1 percent had severe leak. By comparison, currently approved devices have rates of moderate or severe paravalvular leak in the range of 10 to 20 percent. Other alterations allow the valve to be delivered with a smaller catheter, increasing the percentage of procedures that can be performed via the femoral artery, a route preferred because of better outcomes. When transfemoral delivery is not possible, the route is generally through the ribs.
“For the first Sapien devices, we were able to use the less invasive transfemoral approach in about 60 percent of patients,” Kodali said. “For Sapien 3, more than 90 percent of procedures can be transfemoral.”
One-year data for high-risk patients with the new device will be available later in 2015. Longer-term outcomes for the intermediate-risk patients treated with the new device will be compared with the intermediate-risk surgical patients in the PARTNER IIA trial once the two-year endpoint is reached. Patients will be followed for five years.
“We needed to see if we’ve solved the valve leakage issue before we move to lower-risk patients,” Kodali said. “Although we have to wait for longer-term data, what we’ve seen thus far makes us excited about those data and what they’ll show.”
Kodali emphasized that these are 30-day data and that longer-term follow up is required.
Edwards Lifesciences sponsored the trial. The hospital conducts training programs for the company, and Kodali receives compensation from the company for travel related to the trial.
Editor’s note: Michael Davidson, a surgeon from Boston and one of the original PARTNER clinical trial investigators, was killed in January at the age of 44 by the son of a former patient. ACC and the PARTNER trial team dedicate this presentation and journal paper to his memory.
For more information: acc.org