Feature | October 29, 2014

Study: Influential Colleagues Push Doctors to Quickly Adopt New Treatments

Suggestions every five to seven days most effective way to persuade doctors to try new therapies

October 29, 2014 — Doctors are more likely to try a new therapy when they are persuaded to do so by an influential colleague, reports a new Northwestern University study whose findings on adopting innovations also have relevance for business, education and research.

The authors have used the new finding to simulate a technology intervention that acts like an influential colleague—opinionated but not too bossy—that they plan to design for the real world. The goal is to accelerate physicians' adoption of new treatments and tests, which historically can take up to 17 years.

"It's difficult to get doctors to adopt new therapies because you are invading people's comfort zones and the way they usually do things," said lead author Curtis Weiss, M.D., assistant professor of medicine at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine and a physician at Northwestern Memorial Hospital (NMH.)

By analyzing physician social networks, the authors examined how doctors are professionally connected and pass information to each other and how that leads to increasing adoption.

The paper, also by senior author Luis Amaral, professor of chemical and biological engineering at the McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Science and a professor of medicine at Feinberg, was published Oct. 15 in the journal Physical Review X, the journal of the American Physical Society.

The current belief is physicians "catch" a new therapy in what is known as a contagion model. One doctor sees another doctor prescribing a drug or ordering a test, and she will catch or be infected by that new approach and start using it herself.

But the Northwestern study found the art of persuasion was more effective at boosting adoption. The trick was finding the sweet spot in frequency and tone of those persuasive messages so they're effective but not off-putting.

The nudging sweet spot? A reminder every five to seven days delivered as a strong suggestion but not an order, according to the study.

"While our study is focused on critical care physicians, our findings are relevant for other settings in education, research and business where small groups of highly qualified peers make decisions about the adoption of innovations whose utility is difficult if not impossible to gauge," Amaral said.

It's a surprisingly long road from Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of a new drug or technique to doctors actually using the new drug in their practices, noted Weiss, whose research focuses on how to get doctors to adopt best practices.

"The traditional model is a study is published in a journal and discussed at medical conferences, and then doctors in that field were supposed to integrate that into their clinical practice," Weiss said. "The problem with that is doctors are busy and don't always read the journals or go to those conferences. But the bigger issue is even if you read the article and go to the conference, if you don't see a patient with that condition for six months, you may have forgotten the therapy. And there's no follow-up or reinforcement after the conference about how to use it."

The authors analyzed the social networks of critical care physicians in the medical intensive care unit (ICU) at NMH. The test case was a new high-impact serum assay or blood test that measures an enzyme shown to be a marker of life-threatening bacterial infections and sepsis in critically ill patients. The assay has been reported in medical literature as an effective marker but is not yet a part of the guidelines for care. The current way to diagnose infection is a culture but those results take 48 to 72 hours. A quicker diagnosis may improve patient treatment.

Prior to the study, Northwestern didn't have the assay available in its lab. Weiss learned the assay was going to become available and convinced the lab director not to tell anyone before the experiment. Weiss and Amaral then seeded information about the new serum to two other ICU physicians chosen at random. The authors tracked the adoption of the assay over the next nine months, during which time 20 out of 36 doctors adopted the assay.

"We discovered the persuasion model was more accurate in explaining the number and pattern of physicians who started to use the assay," Weiss said.

A computer simulation based on the experimental data aimed at optimizing adoption showed a reminder every five to seven days delivered as a strong suggestion but not an order would have had the greatest impact in accelerating adoption of the new test.

"Optimized interventions could help increase adoption of best practices in hospitals around the country and increase quality of care," Weiss said.

Next the authors plan to design real-world interventions that deliver the knowledge to physicians and emphasize using the new therapy (or best practice) closer to the point at which they would actually use it.

Weiss and Amaral are considering verbal face-to-face reminders, messages sent to pagers or by email, or automated reminders generated by the electronic health record.

Interventions also can regularly audit doctors' adoption. "It could say 'hey, you only used this 30 percent of the time when you should have used it 100 percent of the time,'" Weiss said.

For more information: www.northwestern.edu

Related Content

FDA Releases New Report Assessing Quality, Safety and Effectiveness of Medical Device Servicing
News | Cardiovascular Business | June 07, 2018
A new report from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) discusses the continued quality, safety and effectiveness...
DAIC Editor Dave Fornell won the 2018 AZBEE national silver award for best blog for "The Future of Cardiology: 17 Technologies to Watch. DAIC magazine - diagnostic and interventional cardiology magazine.
News | Cardiovascular Business | May 14, 2018
May 14, 2018 — Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology (DAIC) magazine was honored with a ...
FDA Announces New Medical Device Safety Action Plan
News | Cardiovascular Business | April 25, 2018
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) released a new Medical Device Safety Action Plan outlining how the agency...
DAIC Wins Two 2018 Regional Azbee Awards for Editorial Excellence
Feature | Cardiovascular Business | April 20, 2018
Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology was honored with a pair of Azbee Awards for editorial excellence at the 2018...
DAIC Editor Dave Fornell displays the 2018 Neal Award for Best Use of Social Media
News | Cardiovascular Business | April 05, 2018
April 5, 2018 — Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology (DAIC) magazine received the 2018 Jesse H.
Veritas Capital Acquiring Three Software Units from GE Healthcare
News | Cardiovascular Business | April 02, 2018
GE Healthcare announced the sale of its Value-Based Care Division — including its software assets for Enterprise...
The annual Azbee Awards are hosted by the American Society of Business Publication Editors (ASBPE) to recognize editorial and design excellence in the business, trade and specialty press. Dave Fornell won blog award for DAIC
News | Cardiovascular Business | March 08, 2018
Scranton Gillette Communications’ Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology (DAIC) was recently named a 2018
Fysicon announced its acquisition by Canon Medical Systems Corporation.
News | Cardiovascular Business | March 08, 2018
Fysicon announced its acquisition by Canon Medical Systems Corporation. Linda Elberse, CEO of Fysicon, stated: "Being...
ACC 2018 Cardiovascular Summit Teaches Cardiology Best Practices
News | Cardiovascular Business | February 28, 2018
The American College of Cardiology’s Cardiovascular Summit will begin on Thursday, Feb. 22, 2018, bringing together...
FDA Releases Final Rule on Data Acceptance from Medical Device Clinical Investigations
News | Cardiovascular Business | February 21, 2018
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued the final rule on “Human Subject Protection; Acceptance of Data from...
Overlay Init