News | Stroke | September 07, 2021

Carotid Surgery Versus Stenting Have Similar Long-term Effects on Stroke

ACST-2 trial late-breaker at ESC 2021 was the largest study to compare the long-term effect of CAS versus CEA

A 3-D CT reconstructed image showing a narrow lesion at the carotid bifurcation. ACST-2 was the largest trial to compare the long-term effect of carotid artery stenting (CAS) and carotid endarterectomy (CEA) on stroke in asymptomatic patients with a severely narrowed carotid artery that had not yet caused a stroke. Image by Canon

A 3-D CT reconstructed image showing a narrow lesion at the carotid bifurcation. ACST-2 was the largest trial to compare the long-term effect of carotid artery stenting (CAS) and carotid endarterectomy (CEA) on stroke in asymptomatic patients with a severely narrowed carotid artery that had not yet caused a stroke. Image by Canon


September 7, 2021 — Carotid artery surgery and stenting have comparable long-term effects on fatal or disabling stroke in asymptomatic patients with severe carotid artery stenosis. The ACST-2 trial late-breaking  Hot Line session at the European Cardiology Society (ESC) Congress 2021 was published simultaneously in The Lancet.[1]

Patients with severe carotid artery stenosis are at elevated risk of stroke and both carotid artery stenting (CAS) and carotid artery surgery, also called carotid endarterectomy (CEA), can restore patency and reduce the long-term risk of stroke. Nationwide registry data from Germany have shown among asymptomatic patients, CAS and CEA are both associated with an approximately 1% risk of disabling stroke or death.[2] Comparative data are lacking on the long-term protective effects of the two procedures.

“We have shown that, for patients with a severely narrowed carotid artery, stenting and surgery have similar effects on the chances of having a disabling or fatal stroke. The risk from each procedure is about 1%. After that, however, the annual risk over the next five or more years is halved, from 1% down to 0.5% per year,” explained principal investigator Professor Alison Halliday of the University of Oxford, U.K.

ACST-2 was the largest trial to compare the long-term effect of CAS versus CEA on stroke in asymptomatic patients with a severely narrowed carotid artery that had not yet caused a stroke. The trial enrolled patients with severe carotid artery narrowing (60% or more reduction in diameter on ultrasound) found by chance, but with no recent stroke or other neurological symptoms. Participants were thought by their doctor to need CAS or CEA but both doctor and patient were substantially uncertain about which procedure was preferable.

A total of 3,625 patients were enrolled from 130 centres in 33 countries. Participants were randomly allocated 1:1 to CAS or CEA and followed up for an average of five years. The main outcomes were: 1) procedural risks (morbidity and mortality within one month after the procedure); and, most importantly, 2) non-procedural stroke, subdivided by severity.

Regarding procedural risks, 1% of patients in both groups had a disabling stroke or died within 30 days (15 allocated to CAS and 18 to CEA) and 2% had a non-disabling procedural stroke (48 allocated to CAS and 29 to CEA).

The main outcome was five-year non-procedural stroke; fatal or disabling stroke occurred in 2.5% of patients in each group, for a rate ratio (RR) of CAS versus CEA of 0.98 (95% confidence interval [CI] 0.64–1.48; p=0.91), and any non-procedural stroke occurred in 5.3% of the CAS group versus 4.5% of the CEA group (RR 1.16; 95% CI 0.86–1.57; p=0.33). A meta-analysis of this and all other major trials of CAS versus CEA yielded a similarly non-significant result for any stroke (RR 1.11; 95% CI 0.91–1.32; p=0.21).

ACST-2 is currently funded from the core support from the Medical Research Council (MRC), the British Heart Foundation, and Cancer Research UK for the University of Oxford’s NDPH. The trial had grants from the BUPA Foundation (BUPAF/33a/05) and National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Assessment program (HTA06/301/233) until 2013.

 

Find more ESC Hot Line late-breaking study news

 

References:

1. Second asymptomatic carotid surgery trial (ACST-2): a randomised comparison of carotid artery stenting versus carotid endarterectomy. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)01910-3 (online 29 August 2021 in The Lancet)

2. Institut für Qualitätssicherung und Transparenz im Gesundheitswesen (IQTiG). Karotis-Revaskularisation. https://iqtig. org/qs-verfahren/qs-karotis


Related Content

News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

April 20, 2023 — Researchers led by Northwestern University and the University of Texas at Austin (UT) have developed ...

Home April 20, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

April 5, 2023 — Acarix, a leader in acoustic and AI-based cardiac diagnostics, announced the release of a new study ...

Home April 05, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 29, 2023 — Irregular sleep patterns may play a role in the pathophysiologic development of cardiovascular disease ...

Home March 29, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 27, 2023 — Tenax Therapeutics, Inc., a specialty pharmaceutical company focused on identifying, developing and ...

Home March 27, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 24, 2023 — Vaxxinity, Inc., a Cape Canaveral, FL-based company pioneering the development of a new class of ...

Home March 24, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 22, 2023 — Ancora Heart, Inc., a privately-held Santa Clara, CA-based company developing a completely ...

Home March 22, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 21, 2023 — The first platform to combine real-world cardiology data from millions of people in multiple European ...

Home March 21, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 13, 2023 — BioCardia, Inc., developer of cellular and cell-derived therapeutics for the treatment of ...

Home March 13, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 8, 2023 — A unique community-based partnership, the African American Heart Study, will be conducted to measure the ...

Home March 08, 2023
Home
News | Cardiovascular Clinical Studies

March 6, 2023 — A multifaceted intervention to improve prescribing practices increased the likelihood that patients with ...

Home March 06, 2023
Home
Subscribe Now