Feature | September 11, 2012

Maquet Study Results May Invalidate Industry Standard for Treating Cardiogenic Shock

The Impella percutaneous left ventricular assist devices (pLVAD) is an emerging option for partial or total circulatory support. In several randomized, controlled trials, pLVAD therapy demonstrated a better hemodynamic profile compared to IABP, although this did not translate into improved 30-day survival with use of pLVAD therapy.

September 11, 2012 — Primary results from an ongoing trial by Maquet Cardiovascular using intra-aortic balloon pumps (IABP) as an adjuvant treatment for myocardial infarction (MI) complicated by cardiogenic shock have shown no difference in patient survival when compared to standard care alone. Although IABP proved to be safe, the study’s results provide little evidence that use of IABP therapy is associated with hemodynamic improvement, a trait that has been considered critical to its clinical application for more than 40 years. The IABP-SHOCK II trial, conducted between 37 centers in Germany with 600 randomized patients over the course of three years, represents the largest trial ever performed in cardiogenic shock.

Since their introduction in 1968, IABPs have been the most widely used support device in the treatment of MI complicated by cardiogenic shock, with several million people having received treatment using IABP therapy to date. IABP provides temporary, mechanical circulatory support in an attempt to create a more favorable balance of oxygen supply and demand. Through systolic unloading and diastolic augmentation, the cardiac output, ejection fraction (EF) and rate of coronary perfusion are increased, while left ventricular wall stress, systemic resistance to left EF, and pulmonary capillary wedge pressure are decreased. Use of IABP therapy for cardiogenic shock patients during the ‘80s and ‘90s was limited to around 20 percent of cases; however, there has been a temporal trend towards increased use over the years, with rates currently estimated at 25 to 40 percent.

Until now, only a few registry studies and clinical trials have shown that IABP therapy can improve blood pressure and the perfusion of the coronary arteries. Based on this limited data, international guidelines recommend the use of IABP therapy in patients with cardiogenic shock, although, as evident in the frequency of use, many cardiologists are still not entirely convinced of its efficacy. It was for this reason that the IABP-SHOCK II trial was initiated, aiming to provide evidence that use of IABP therapy, currently a Class I recommendation, would reduce the 30-day mortality rate in patients compared to standard care. Besides failing to reduce rates of mortality, use of IABP showed no improvement in blood pressure, no reduction in treatment time in the intensive care unit, no decrease in the duration or dose of drugs prescribed and no improvement in organ perfusion. Several subgroups were additionally evaluated and also showed no clear benefit in using IABP.

While IABP therapy is currently the workhorse circulatory support device used by cardiovascular specialists, GlobalData believes that the Class I recommendation will now be strongly challenged. Previous studies have explored the use of IABP and even reported positive results; however, no trials have had the breadth, statistical significance and randomization of the SHOCK II trial. With this most recent announcement of SHOCK II’s primary results, it is expected that cardiologists will further question continued use of IABP therapy, although six-month and 12-month mortality data must be assessed before any definitive conclusions can be made.

Treatment strategies for patients with cardiogenic shock have come to a key turning point, and results of this most recent IABP trial have left a therapeutic void to fill. Percutaneous left ventricular assist devices (pLVAD) represent an emerging option for partial or total circulatory support and more than one study has compared the safety and efficacy of these devices with IABP. In several randomized, controlled trials, pLVAD therapy demonstrated a better hemodynamic profile compared to IABP, although this did not translate into improved 30-day survival with use of pLVAD therapy. The most common pLVADs studied currently are the TandemHeart developed by CardiacAssist and the Abiomed Impella LP2.5. As pLVAD technology continues to improve, further studies will be required to determine its effectiveness. Muscular counterpulsation exemplifies a noninvasive alternative to IABP therapy and has shown some promise, although more clinical research must be conducted before conclusions can be made.

Besides Maquet, who recently acquired Datascope’s cardiovascular portfolio, other companies with IABP products include Arrow and Abiomed. The results of the SHOCK II study provide a huge opportunity to develop novel and innovative strategies to treat cardiogenic shock, and room for another company to seize market control for this indication. GlobalData expects IABP therapy will be targeted to a more specific target population in future studies where it is deemed most effective, and that pLVAD therapy may undergo further development to improve survival rates.

For more information: www.globaldata.com/ExpertsInsightDetails.aspx?PRID=347&companyID=jpr

Related Content

Biotronik, BioMonitor 2 implantable cardiac monitor, BioInsight clinical study, first patients enrolled
News | Implantable Cardiac Monitor (ICM)| January 20, 2017
Biotronik has enrolled the first patients in the BioInsight clinical study evaluating the safety and feasibility of...
ICDs, non-ischemic cardiomyopathy, University of Alabama at Birmingham study, Circulation
News | Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICD)| January 18, 2017
A new study published in Circulation has found there is a 23 percent risk in reduction of all-cause mortality in non-...
stress, brain activity, cardiovascular risk, PET-CT, MGH, ISSMS, The Lancet study
News | Cardiac Diagnostics| January 18, 2017
A study led by Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) and Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai (ISSMS) investigators...
ICDs, implantable cardioverter defibrillators, survival rate, elderly patients, JACC study
News | Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillators (ICD)| January 17, 2017
Of patients over age 65 who received an implantable cardioverter-defibrillator (ICD) after surviving sudden cardiac...
University of Utah, Frank Sachse, heart failure, LVAD implantation, left ventricular assist device, biomarker, t-system

Two patients may seem equally sick based upon clinical measures, but differences in their heart physiology could predict who has the potential to recover from heart failure. A study carried out by scientists at the University of Utah finds that patients whose hearts have flattened t-tubules have a decreased chance of showing signs of recovery after implanting a mechanical heart pump. Ordinarily, t-tubules in the heart are long, thin, and rounded. Image courtesy of Frank Sachse.

News | Cardiac Diagnostics| January 17, 2017
Investigators at the University of Utah have identified distinct differences in the hearts of advanced heart failure...
Synergy stent, abluminal polymer DES, bioresorbable polymer DES, bioresorbable polymer metallic stent

The Synergy stent is the first FDA cleared drug-eluting stent to use a bioresorbable polymer drug carrier. When the polymer dissolves after about four months, the devices become a bare metal stent. The technology is supposed to reduce the rate of late stent thrombosis due to vessel inflammation caused by durable polymers.

Feature | Stents Bioresorbable| January 17, 2017 | Dave Fornell
One of the big advancements in drug-eluting stent (DES) technology has been the development of bioresorbable polymers
St. Jude Medical, Amplatzer Amulet LAA Occluder, observational study, TCT 2016
News | Left Atrial Appendage (LAA) Occluders| November 03, 2016
St. Jude Medical Inc. presented favorable results from the largest observational study to date of the company’s...
Medtronic, CoreValve Evolut R TAVR system, U.S. IDE Study, TCT 2016
News | Heart Valve Technology| November 03, 2016
Medtronic plc unveiled new clinical data showing that patients treated with the self-expanding CoreValve Evolut R...
open-heart surgery, PCI, percutaneous coronary intervention, NOBLE trial, left main coronary artery disease, LMCAD, TCT 2016
News | Cardiovascular Surgery| November 03, 2016
Coronary artery bypass (CABG) surgery is the standard treatment for revascularization in patients with left main...
News | Drug-Eluting Balloons| November 03, 2016
The Spectranetics Corp. announced that it has submitted to the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) its Pre-Market...
Overlay Init