Dave Fornell is the editor of DAIC magazine at TCT.

Dave Fornell, DAIC Editor at TCT

Blog | Dave Fornell, DAIC Editor at TCT Cath Lab| October 16, 2018

The Innovation Cycle for New Cardiovascular Technology

The cardiovascular innovation cycle presented by TCT Course Director Martin Leon, M.D. at TCT 2018. #TCT2018 #TCT #TCT18

The cardiovascular innovation cycle, presented by TCT Course Director Martin Leon, M.D., at TCT 2018.


There is a hype cycle surrounding new technologies in all industries, but medicine is unique because of its focus on clinical trial data as one of the key determining factors of whether a new device becomes standard of care or dies on the vine. Here is a great summary of this cycle with cardiovascular devices.

Over the past decade of covering the Transcatheter Cardiovascular Therapeutics (TCT) meetings, I have seen an interesting slide on the innovation cycle for interventional cardiology device technologies presented numerous times by Course Director Martin B. Leon, M.D., director of the Center for Interventional Vascular Therapy and professor of medicine, NewYork-Presbyterian, Columbia University Medical Center. The slide is always the same since he first presented it at TCT in 1993, but it holds universally true today in 2018. 

Leon said the cycle starts with the introduction of a new technology that garners unbridled enthusiasm because of the promise the technology holds to solve problems with the current standard of care. The early data seems great and when it enters the market, there is rapid adoption as everyone wants to try to use it. However, there are inevitably some complications that are discovered once the technology is used on a large scale, either due to implant, operator skill or previously unknown complications. When data on the complications are presented, there is a steep drop-off in the use of the technology. 

At this point in the cycle, Leon said it is important to refine the technology to overcome the issues presented by the first-generation device. Once that is achieved and clinical data confirms the issues are resolved, there is a second wave of adoption for the technology, as cardiologists are cautiously optimistic about using the improved technology. He said that crash where the enthusiasm dissolves because of cold, hard data is when the real science of refining the technology into something better can take place. 

Certainly this cycle mirrored the case with drug-eluting stents and the discovery of polymer-related late-stent thrombosis. The same is true with renal denervation and bioresorbable stents.

At TCT 2018, Leon used this slide in sessions to describe where interventional cardiology is at today with bioresorbable stent technology — at the bottom of the abyss. However, he said there are new bioresorbable technologies still being developed that already hold promise to resolve the issues inherent with the first-generation Absorb stent. This includes new bioresorbable scaffolds (BRS) that use different polymers to possibly avoid late thrombosis, and devices with the same strut thickness of today's metallic stents to make the devices easier to deliver and allow use in smaller vessels. 

Two years ago, all TCT sessions on bioresorbable technologies were packed and it seemed as if metallic stents had no long-term future. What a difference a year makes from TCT 2017, when the poor ABSORB III Trial data was presented and Abbott pulled the Absorb off the market. At TCT 2018, bioresorbable technology definitely took a back seat to metallic stent presentations, where the industry has definitely refocused its interest. 

"I want to be a wild enthusiast, not a doubting skeptic," Leon said about BRS technology. "The Absorb was not easy to use and there was a safety concern. The safety signal is really what distracted people's attention with bioresorbable stents. We are not going to have an avalanche of new bioresorbable stents, but there will be a few second-generation stents that have overcome the limitations of the first-generation stent."

However, the new clinical evidence will have to be persuasive enough with these new BRS devices to convince him and the rest of the interventional cardiology community that the technology is truly ready for prime time.

Read the article from TCT 2018 "The Next Step in Bioresorbable Stent Technologies."

Watch an interview with Patrick Serruys, M.D., about the future of BVS technology.
 

Related Content

News | Cardiovascular Business

May 25, 2022 — MedStar Heart & Vascular Institute announced that Thomas E. MacGillivray, MD, has been named physician ...

Home May 25, 2022
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

May 16, 2022 — Boston Scientific announced that Peter M. “Pete” Nicholas, co-founder and former CEO of Boston Scientific ...

Home May 16, 2022
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

May 12, 2022 — Abbott announced a new partnership with Women as One to launch a new program designed to train more ...

Home May 12, 2022
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

May 12, 2022 — NDA Partners General Manager, Eric Fish, announced today that Peter Mackrell, MD, a board certified ...

Home May 12, 2022
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

May 11, 2022 — Vital Heart & Vein, a leading provider of cardiovascular and vein health, has named Gay Nord as its new ...

Home May 11, 2022
Home
Feature | Cardiovascular Business

Here are the top 10 performing videos on the Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology (DAIC) website during the month of ...

Home May 09, 2022
Home
Feature | Cardiovascular Business | By Melinda Taschetta-Millane

Here is what you and your colleagues found to be most interesting in the field of cardiology during the month of April ...

Home May 02, 2022
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business
April 29, 2022 – Providing excellent care inside and outside of the traditional hospital is the new normal for patients ...
Home April 29, 2022
Home
Feature | Cardiovascular Business | By Melinda Taschetta-Millane

You could feel the energy and excitement at the 2022 HIMSS Global Health Conference & Exhibition (HIMSS22) held this ...

Home April 29, 2022
Home
News | Cardiovascular Business

April 28, 2022 — Today, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), through the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid ...

Home April 28, 2022
Home
Subscribe Now