News | July 10, 2008

Researcher Says RFID Devices are Much Safer than Dutch Study Suggests

July 11, 2008 - A new study that found wireless systems that track hospital medical equipment can cause potentially hazardous incidents involving lifesaving devices may have caused needless alarmed, says a biomedical engineering technology professor at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI).

Barbara Christe, who directs the biomedical engineering technology program in the Purdue School of Engineering and Technology at IUPUI, said this week a study that she completed in March 2008 and has been accepted for publication in Biomedical Instrumentation and Technology found the wireless systems using Radio-Frequency Identification (RFID) devices did not interfere with or influence the performance of commonly used medical devices such as physiological monitors and intravenous pumps in general patient care rooms. This disputes claims in a recent Dutch study that claimed RFID does cause interference.

“The use of RFID systems to manage inventory, track items and ease patient billing data collection can be used in general patient care rooms without concern of adverse device performance,” Christe said.

The most basic RFID system typically includes four pieces of equipment: a host computer, a transceiver, an antenna, and a tag.

The study does note that as new RFID components and systems are introduced in the future, further study may be necessary to evaluate RFID technology and its impact on medical equipment.

The study warning of electromagnetic interference from RFID devices inducing potentially hazardous incidents was published June 25 in the Journal of the American Medical Association by Dutch researchers. These researchers examined a wider range of medical equipment than did Christe, including critical care equipment not commonly found in general patient care rooms.

However, Christe said the Dutch study did not attempt to reproduce a setting that would typically be found in a hospital for the tests they conducted, as she did with her study. In fact, the conclusions of the Dutch study refer to a “controlled nonclinical setting.”

The Dutch researchers tested RFID devices as close as .1 cm from medical equipment, which she said is very unlikely in real world use, since the RFID purpose is to track assets without physical contact, Christe said. RFID antennas are generally placed in a doorway or a corner of a room.

In Christe’s study, RFID antennas were placed as close as one foot from medical equipment. Even that distance, she said, is far closer than would typically be the case in a patient’s room. No interference was found in 1,600 tests she conducted in a patient room at Community North Hospital in Indianapolis. Christe tested pumps, noninvasive blood pressure monitors, pulse oximetry monitors, ECG monitors and sequential compression devices using two common RFID antennas, near field and far field.

The Dutch study tested the impact of RFID devices on medical equipment in a manner that was anything but a typical use setting, Christe said.

“If I swallow my cell phone, I may have some type of hazardous interaction, but that is not an appropriate or typical use of a cell phone,” she said.

For more information:

Related Content

First-in-Human Results Show Early Bird Device Effective in Early Detection of Internal Bleeding
News | Patient Monitors | June 18, 2019
New study results validate the effectiveness of the Saranas Early Bird Bleed Monitoring System to sense bleeding events...
Lexington Biosciences Concludes Initial HeartSentry Clinical Study
News | Patient Monitors | August 16, 2018
Lexington Biosciences Inc. recently announced the completion of the initial HeartSentry study conducted at San...
Itamar Medical Launches SleePath for AFib Patients at Heart Rhythm 2018
Technology | Patient Monitors | May 16, 2018
Itamar Medical Ltd. announced the launch of SleePath, the first integrated e-health sleep apnea care pathway monitoring...
News | Patient Monitors | March 09, 2018
Philips recently announced the integration of its IntelliVue Guardian with automated Early Warning Scoring (EWS) into...
Acarix, CADScor System, coronary artery disease detection, clinical study, ACC.17
News | Patient Monitors | March 30, 2017
Acarix AB recently announced the results from a new multi-center trial of its handheld CADScor System for non-invasive...
Corsens Medical, Corsens Cardiac Monitor, FDA 510(k) clearance
Technology | Patient Monitors | December 08, 2016
Corsens Medical Ltd. announced that it has received clearance for a Pre-Marketing Notification (510(k)) with the U.S....
Corsens Cardiac Monitor, FDA 510k pre-market notification
News | Patient Monitors | May 26, 2016
Corsens Medical Ltd. announced it has successfully completed filing of a Pre-Marketing Notification (510(k)) with the U...
Philips, FDA 510k clearance, Expression MR400, MRI patient monitor
Technology | Patient Monitors | February 11, 2016
Royal Philips announced U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) 510(k) clearance for the Expression MR400, a new...
Profusa, integrated biosensors, long-term continuous monitoring
News | Patient Monitors | January 15, 2016
Biointegrated sensors for long-term, continuous tracking of body chemistry may make health and disease monitoring as...
sleep apnea, pulse oximetery, congestive heart failure, CHF, pulse-oximetry, Thomas Jefferson University
News | Patient Monitors | September 09, 2015
Researchers at Thomas Jefferson University showed that a simple questionnaire, evaluation and pulse-oximetry monitoring...