News | Heart Valve Technology | March 09, 2017

Boston Scientific Receives Favorable Rulings In Edwards Lifesciences TAVR Litigation

Edwards Found to Infringe on Boston Scientific Patents in Germany and U.K.

Boston Scientific Lotus TAVR valve, Lotus transcatheter aortic valve

March 9, 2017 — Boston Scientific announced the German District Court of Düsseldorf has determined that Edwards Lifesciences and its German subsidiary's Sapien 3 device infringed two patents of Boston Scientific Scimed Inc. related to the seals for transcatheter heart valves. The seals help prevent paravalvular leak around the valve after it is implanted, which is a feature of both the Boston Scientific Lotus transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) system and the Edwards Sapien 3 TAVR system.

The court said the two patents violated by Edwards are the German parts of EP 2 749 254 B1 and EP 2 926 766 B1.

Boston Scientific and its German subsidiary were also found not to infringe upon Edwards' German part of EP 1 441 672 B1. However, the court did find Boston infringed upon Edwards' German part of EP 2 399 550 B1. Boston Scientific said its believes the '550 patent will be revoked by the European Patent Office (EPO). Edwards said it will promptly request an appeal the decision.

The Lotus Valve System is designed for aortic valve replacement in patients with severe aortic stenosis who are considered at high risk for surgical valve replacement. Instead of open heart surgery, the replacement valve is delivered via transcatheter percutaneous delivery. The Lotus Valve Adaptive Seal is a technology that creates an external seal to prevent leakage around the valve known as paravalvular leak or PVL, which is a proven predictor of mortality.[1,2,3]

Edwards Lifesciences and Boston Scientific can appeal each of the four decisions as far as the District Court of Düsseldorf has decided against them. Each company has opposed the other's patents in the EPO.

This decision in Germany follows the March 3, 2017, ruling from the Patents Court of the High Court of Justice in England, which also ruled in favor of Boston Scientific Scimed Inc., finding that Edwards' Sapien 3 device infringes Boston Scientific patent EP (UK) 2 926 766 and that all claims of that patent were valid. Edwards has stated that it will try to appeal this judgment.

"We will continue to protect our intellectual property to ensure we can continue to bring forward innovative technologies that make a meaningful difference in the lives of patients," said Tim Pratt, executive vice president, chief administrative officer, general counsel and secretary, Boston Scientific. "We are pleased with the progress we are making with litigation in Europe, and believe the strength of our intellectual property will also be upheld in U.S. cases involving the same patents."

The Lotus Valve is currently not available for use or sale due to a recall of the device by Boston Scientific.

References:

1. Kodali SK et al. “Two-Year Outcomes after Transcatheter or Surgical Aortic-Valve Replacement.” N Engl J Med 2012; 366:1686-1695 
2. Tamburino C et al. “Incidence and Predictors of Early and Late Mortality After Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation in 663 Patients With Severe Aortic Stenosis.” Circ. 2011;123:299. 
3. Abdel-Wahab M et al. “Aortic Regurgitation After Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation: Incidence and Early Outcome. Results from the German Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation Registry.” Heart 2011;97:899-906.

 

Related Content

Average Age of U.S. Cardiologists Up While Income is Down
News | Cardiovascular Business | October 25, 2018
Overall cardiology compensation has dropped for the first time since 2014, according to the sixth annual Cardiovascular...
American Heart Association and The Joint Commission Merge Cardiac Certification Programs
News | Cardiovascular Business | October 15, 2018
The nation’s two leading cardiac accreditation and certification organizations are joining forces to offer a single...
A hands-on-training session at TCT 2018 that instructed interventional cardiologists how to use an intra-cardiac echo (ICE) catheter to image the chambers inside the heart with a catheter based ultrasound imaging system.  The training area was sponsored by Siemens Healthineers

A Siemens-sponsored hands-on-training session at TCT 2018 that instructed interventional cardiologists how to use an intra-cardiac echo (ICE) catheter to image the chambers inside the heart with a catheter based ultrasound imaging system.  Regular training is needed to build customer satisfaction, especially in light of regular staff turnover.

Feature | Cardiovascular Business | October 10, 2018 | John Larson
Years ago, I owned a computer that ran a spreadsheet program called Lotus 1-2-3.
ZHealth Launches Etch Cardiovascular Coding Software
Technology | Cardiovascular Business | October 10, 2018
October 10, 2018 — Medical coding software provider ZHealth recently unveiled Etch, the first-ever software platform
GlobalData: Amazon Poised to Make Huge Strides in Healthcare
News | Cardiovascular Business | August 31, 2018
A new report from data and analytics company GlobalData suggests that Amazon is poised to make huge strides in...
CMS Proposes Overhaul of Medicare's Accountable Care Organization Program
News | Cardiovascular Business | August 09, 2018
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a proposed rule August 9 that would overhaul the Medicare...
ECRI Institute Announces New Clinical Guideline Repository Website
News | Cardiovascular Business | July 27, 2018
July 27, 2018 — Following the deactivation of the National Guideline Clearinghouse (NGC) by the Agency for Healthcare
FDA Releases New Report Assessing Quality, Safety and Effectiveness of Medical Device Servicing
News | Cardiovascular Business | June 07, 2018
A new report from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) discusses the continued quality, safety and effectiveness...
DAIC Editor Dave Fornell won the 2018 AZBEE national silver award for best blog for "The Future of Cardiology: 17 Technologies to Watch. DAIC magazine - diagnostic and interventional cardiology magazine.
News | Cardiovascular Business | May 14, 2018
May 14, 2018 — Diagnostic and Interventional Cardiology (DAIC) magazine was honored with a ...
FDA Announces New Medical Device Safety Action Plan
News | Cardiovascular Business | April 25, 2018
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) released a new Medical Device Safety Action Plan outlining how the agency...
Overlay Init