News | Wearables | August 24, 2022

Wrist-Worn Devices are Shown by Mass General Researchers to be Cost-Effective for Screening of Atrial Fibrillation

A study simulating a population of 30 million people 65 and older found that wrist-wearable devices are more cost-effective than traditional electrocardiograms and pulse palpation for atrial fibrillation (AF) screening, and that they are associated with a reduction in stroke incidence 

A study simulating a population of 30 million people 65 and older found that wrist-wearable devices are more cost-effective than traditional electrocardiograms and pulse palpation for atrial fibrillation (AF) screening, and that they are associated with a reduction in stroke incidence

Getty Images

August 24, 2022 —  Screening individuals for atrial fibrillation (AF) using wearable devices is more cost-effective than screening using conventional methods such as 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) and pulse palpation, or than no screening at all, researchers from Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) have found. 

In a study in JAMA Health Forum, the team reported that use of contemporary wrist-worn wearables was also associated with a reduction in stroke incidence and could help to detect less frequent AF episodes through its ability to monitor for potentially irregular heart rhythm on a near-continuous basis. 

“The proliferation of wrist-worn devices for AF detection provides a convenient option for population-wide screening, though it’s not known if their use will lead to increased costs and problems related to follow-up testing and false positives,” says co-senior author Jagpreet Chhatwal, PhD, director of the MGH Institute for Technology Assessment. 

“We therefore simulated a virtual trial comparing clinical and cost outcomes under different AF screening strategies, and showed that those using wrist-worn devices generally resulted in greater benefits compared to traditional modalities, and at a cost deemed affordable to the healthcare system.” 

Atrial fibrillation is the most common type of heart arrhythmia, and undiagnosed AF is the leading cause of stroke. Studies have shown that population-based screening for AF could result in earlier initiation of oral anticoagulation therapy to prevent AF-related stroke, though current health system guidelines conflict. 

Cardiology societies in Europe and Australia/New Zealand, for example, recommend screening using pulse palpation or ECG rhythm strips (both typically conducted in physician offices) for individuals aged 65 and over, while the United States Preventive Services Task Force has concluded there is insufficient evidence to recommend AF screening using ECG. 

At a time when more and more consumers are adopting wearable devices, MGH researchers tested eight screening strategies – six using wrist-worn wearables and two employing pulse palpation and ECG. 

The six included devices using two types of technology: photoplethysmography (PPG), that is, non-invasive use of a light source at the wrist to measure changes in blood volume as an indicator of the pulse, and ECG, composed of single-lead wearables that use sensors attached to the skin to detect the electrical activity of the heart (the two technologies are often available on the same device, such as the latest iterations of Apple Watch and Fitbit). 

Using a model that simulates a 30-million-person cohort of people 65 and older, researchers found the “economically preferred” strategy to be wrist-wearable PPG, followed by wrist-worn ECG accompanied by a clinical-grade rhythm monitoring patch worn on the body for two weeks for confirmation. 

“We believe our findings provide justification for integrating wrist-worn wearables into AF screening programs, and potentially targeting populations younger than the typically recommended age of 65 for AF screening, perhaps even as low as age 50,” says co-lead author Shaan Khurshid, MD, MPH, an electrophysiology fellow at MGH. “Moreover, the ability to use these monitoring devices over extended periods could lead to the detection of infrequent paroxysmal AF, which is otherwise very difficult for clinicians to diagnose.” 

Adds co-senior author Steven Lubitz, MD, MPH, cardiac electrophysiologist at MGH, “Our study could potentially trigger additional research to determine how wrist-worn screening can best be deployed to improve AF-related outcomes, such as stroke prevention.” 

Another possible avenue of exploration is suggested by co-first author and research scientist Wanyi Chen, PhD: “If wrist-worn devices are more cost-effective, does it then make sense for insurance providers to facilitate even wider deployment by helping to defray the cost for consumers?” 

Chhatwal is an assistant professor of Radiology, Harvard Medical School (HMS). Lubitz is an associate professor of Medicine, HMS. 

The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health and the American Heart Association

For more information: 

Related content: 

Use and Benefits of RPM in a Clinical Setting 

The Future of Cardiac Health 

Mayo Researchers Use AI to Detect Weak Heart Pump via Patients’ Apple Watch ECGs 

Related Content on Wearables and Big Data in Healthcare: 

New Fitbit Feature Makes AFib Detection More Accessible 

Tracking Cardiovascular Health Population Trends Using Consumer Wearables 

Bristol-Myers Squibb-Pfizer Alliance, Fitbit Team Up on Atrial Fibrillation Detection 

Artificial Intelligence Detects AFib Using Apple Watch Heart Rate Sensor 

Consumer Smart Watches Accurately Measure Paroxysmal Supraventricular Tachycardia 

VIDEO: Use of Wearable Medical Devices for Cardiac Rehabilitation — Interview with Robert Klempfner, M.D. 

VIDEO: Mobile App Links Wearable Data to Electronic Medical Records 

Apple Heart Study Demonstrates Ability of Wearable Technology to Detect Atrial Fibrillation 

VIDEO: Use of Wearables to Track Electrophysiology Patients — Interview with Khaldoun Tarakji, M.D. 

VIDEO: The Future of Wearables in Healthcare — Karl Poterack, M.D. 

8 Cardiovascular Technologies to Watch in 2020 

VIDEO: Healthcare Technology Advances at CES 2019 

Welcoming Apple to the World of ECG 

Related Content

News | ECG

November 21, 2023 — AccurKardia, an ECG-led diagnostics software company, announced a multi-year agreement with Lucem ...

Home November 21, 2023
News | ECG

October 13, 2023 — InfoBionic, Inc. today announced that it received 510(k) clearance from the U.S. Food and Drug ...

Home October 13, 2023
News | ECG

October 13, 2023 — The newly MDR-certified Cardiomatics solution is accurate, fast and easy-to-use AI-based standalone ...

Home October 13, 2023
News | ECG

September 26, 2023 — Heart Test Laboratories, Inc., an AI-powered medical technology company focused on transforming ...

Home September 26, 2023
News | ECG

September 6, 2023 — Vektor Medical, developer of the only technology to accurately map arrhythmias using just 12-lead ...

Home September 06, 2023
News | ECG

August 15, 2023 — Clario, a healthcare research technology company that delivers leading endpoint technology solutions ...

Home August 15, 2023
News | ECG

July 27, 2023 — Heart Test Laboratories, Inc. d/b/a HeartSciences, an artificial intelligence (AI)-based medical ...

Home July 27, 2023
News | ECG

June 21, 2023 — Anumana, Inc., a leading AI-driven health technology company, has received Breakthrough Device ...

Home June 21, 2023
News | ECG

June 19, 2023 — AliveCor, a global leader in personal electrocardiogram (ECG) technology, has announced a groundbreaking ...

Home June 19, 2023
News | ECG

June 9, 2023 — Mount Sinai researchers have developed an innovative artificial intelligence (AI) model for ...

Home June 09, 2023
Subscribe Now